The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings










A CurtainUp Review

Hadestown Now on Broadway
Even without the usual elements of a hit Broadway musical, Anais Mitchell's folk opera was further developed and got new leads. That production has now made the leap to Broadway's Walter Kerr Theater. Below the current production notes, and after it, my review and song listposted when it opened downtown.

Hadestown at the Walter Kerr Theatre 219 W. 48th St.
From 3/22/19; opening 4/17/19 Directed by Rachel Chavkin. Cast: Reeve Carney, André De Shields, Amber Gray, Eva Noblezada, and Patrick Page.
Set design: Rachel Hauck
Costume desig: Michael Krass
Lightng design: Bradley King
Sound design: Nevin Steinberg and Jessica Paz
It's an old song. . .and we're gonna sing it again— Hermes

Damon Daunno and Nabiyah Be (Photo: Joan Marcus)
The myth of Orpheus is one of those long ago stories that's been told again and again on the page, stage and screen. In Hadestown, an almost sung-through version now at New York Theatre Workshop, the old tale has been brought to fascinating, lushly staged new life.

This musical re-telling actually began as a concept album by singer-songwriter and musician Anaïs Mitchell in 2010. The album led to a concert tour that won a large fan base for the folk and jazz and blues inflected music. When Mitchell and Rachel Chavkin, the dynamic director of Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet Of 1812 met three years ago, they began working together on a theatrical adaptation. And it's the result of that collaboration that makes a trip to New York Theatre Workshop imperative for anyone who appreciates vibrant, original musicals.

While Hadestown hasn't completely shed its album-concert roots, it's not overstating anything when it describes itself as a folk opera. All the songs are there, plus a bunch of new ones and the addition of a narrator named Hermes (Chris Sullivan). This retelling — or to be more specific, re-singing— of the famous myth has been brought into the future. Eurydice and Orpheus fall in love in an unnamed city though the southern jazz and blues infused folk music, Liam Robinson's terrific on-stage band and Michael Krass's costumes evoke a 1940s style New Orleans look.

Eurydice (Nabiyah Be) is now more pro-active in her fate. That means that her less pragmatic, pipe-dreaming lover, Orpheus (Damon Daunno), has to rescue her from the underworld rather than to literally bring her back to life.

The underworld into which the pragmatic Eurydice seeks to escape the hardscrabble life up above is a dreary one-percent dominated industrial place abound which its ruler, an eerily Trump-like Hades (Patrick Page), has built a wall to keep out the needy people up above. Instead of Persephone being Hades' forcefully abducted wife she and he are here a long married, once much in love couple.

But all of Hades' wealth and power have not prevented their love from losing its spark, prompting Persephone to regularly seek relief from boredom and "livin It Up On Top.". No wonder the passion of the young lovers, ignites Hades'interest in Erydice when he sojourns up above to bring Persephone back. The Fates (Lulu Fall, Jessie Shelton and Shaina Taub), serve as a chorus resembling a girl group.

Director Chavkin and scenic designer Rachel Hauck have reconfigured the theater into an arena style space, with the audience seated on mismatched wooden chairs (yes, there are pillows to make them more comfortable) all around the stage with the band at the far end and a balcony space above them. This allows Chavkin to keep the actors entering and moving around through the audience aisles to create an immersive experience.

Since the story revolves around the young lovers with different views of life (he's a dreamer and she more practical) this show could easily have used their names for the title. But Hadestown is indeed the ideal choice given the mood and style of this riveting production and the overall excellence of all the performers. (It's also a sure-fire box office draw for fans of the Hadestown album).

Be and Daunno are both making impressive Off-Broadway debuts as the young lovers. Chris Sullivan's magnetic Hermes couldn't wish for better story-telling support than he gets from the trio playing the Fates. When it comes to portraying a villain with compelling ferocity who could be better than the boom-voiced Patrick Page? And Amber Gray is a truly magnificent Persephone.

Of course, the real star of Hadestown is the music with its well blended mix of folk music, blues-y jazz and pop presented as solos, duets, "instrumental on Top" and "Way Down in Hadestown." The lyrics are also very smart. The all too current events resonating "Why We Build the Wall" done as a call-and-response number by Page and the Fates is one of many highlights.

Rachel Hauk's essentially bare stage is enhanced with a few astutely introduced props by Noah Mease and Bradley King's superb lighting. David Neumann's choreography focuses on movement rather than high kicks, but there's one fun dance by Page and Gray.

Hadestown is the third highly original and enjoyable new musical to debut Off-Broadway. Dear Evan Hansen which has ended its Second Stage run with the announcement of its transfer to Broadway. A Total Bend may well continue the the Public Theater's record-breaking streak of Broadway transfers. I wouldn't be suprised if Hadestown, also ends up moving uptown. But don't wait. Catch it while you can in this smaller, more intimate setting.

list of Sets for the musical numbers which were not listed in the program
Act One
    ROAD TO HELL/Hermes, Company
    COME HOME WITH ME.Orpheus, Eurydice
    WEDDING SONG/Orpheus, Eurydice
    LIVING IT UP ON TOP/Persephone, Orpheus, Company
    ALL I'VE EVER KNOWN/Eurydice, Orpheus
    WAY DOWN HADESTOWN/Hermes, Orpheus, Fates, Eurydice, Company
    WIND THEME - IM WORKING"/Hermes, Eurydice, Orpheus
    EPIC II/Orpheus, Company
    CHANT I/Hades, Persephone, Orpheus, Eurydice, Hermes, Company
    HEY, LITTLE SONGBIRD/Hades, Eurydice
    WHEN THE CHIPS ARE DOWN/Fates, Eurydice
    GONE, I'M GONE/Eurydice, Fates
    WAIT FOR ME INTRO/Hermes, Orpheus
    WAIT FOR ME/Hermes, Orpheus, Company
    WHY WE BUILD THE WALL/Hades, Eurydice, Company
Act Two
    Entr'acte: OUR LADY OF THE UNDERGROUND/Persephone, Company
    WAY DOWN HADESTOWN II/Eurydice, Company
    COME HOME WITH ME II/Orpheus, Eurydice
    PAPERS/Hades, instrumental
    IF IT'S TRUE/Orpheus, Company
    HOW LONG?/Persephone, Hades
    CHANT II/Hades, Persephone, Orpheus, Eurydice, Hermes, Company
    EPIC III/Orpheus, Company
    LOVER'S DESIRE/instrumental
    HIS KISS, THE RIOT/Hades, Fates
    PROMISES/Eurydice, Orpheus
    WAIT FOR ME IHermes, Eurydice, Hades, Persephone, Company
    DOUBT COMES IN/Orpheus, Eurydice, Fates
    ROAD TO HELL II/Hermes, Company
    I RAISE MY CUP TO HIM/Persephone, Company

Search CurtainUp in the box below Back to Curtainup Main Page

Folk opera by Anaïs Mitchell
Directed by Rachel Chavkin
Cast: Nabiyah Be (Eurydice),Damon Daunno (Orpheus), Lulu Fall (Fate), Amber Gray (Persephone), Patrick Page (Hades), Jessie Shelton (Fate), Chris Sullivan (Hermes), Shaina Taub ( Fate).
Scenery by Rachel Hauck
Costumes by Michael Krass
Lighting by Brandley King
Sound by Rob Kaplowitz
Properties: Noah Mease
Arrangements and orchestrations by Michael Chorney
Co-arrangements, orchestrations and music supervision by Todd Sickafoose
Choreography by David Neumann
Dramaturgy by Ken Cerniglia
Music direction by Liam Robinson
Stage Manager: Lindsey Turtletaub
Running Time: 2 hours plus 1 intermission
New York Theatre Workshop 79 E. 4th Street
F From 5/0616; opening 5/23/16; closing 7/03/16.
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer at 5/28 press matinee

Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Hadestown
  • I disagree with the review of Hadestown
  • The review made me eager to see Hadestown
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted at to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter

©Copyright 2016, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from