The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings

A CurtainUp Review
To Kill a Mockingbird

Jeff Daniels will play Atticus Finch until 11/03/19. Ed Harris, another renowned stage and screen actor, will take over the role on 11/05/19. He will be joined by a new cast comprised of Nick Robinson, Eliza Scanlen, Kyle Scatliffe, Lisagay Hamilton, Taylor Trensch, Nina Grollman, Russell Harvard, Emmet Walsh,and more.
You gotta crawl around in another man's skin 'fore you can really know him —Atticus to the children who in Aaron Sorkin's version challenge his insistence in the essential goodness of everyone, thus demanding that all their fellow Maycomb residents must be respected as "friends and neighbors."

They say what doesn't kill you makes you stronger,But what do the things that kill us do?— Calpurnia the African-American Finch family housekeeper in one of several scene in which Aaron Sorkin's script now has her speak out as Lee's 1930s characters like this did not.

I was guilty as soon as I was accused.— Tom Robinson, the novel's other major black character now given more of a voice. His comeback to the still idealistic lawyer's question about why he is inclined to run is "If you were a black man like me, you'd run too."
To Kill a Mockingbird
Jeff Daniels as Atticus Finch and Gbenga Akinnagbe as Tom Robinson (Photo: Julieta Cervantes)
Harper Lee's 1960 novel is a work that has embedded itself into our hearts and minds for half a century— not just for its author's storytelling gifts but her exploration of the race and class issues that have been the dark clouds overhaning this country's uplifting history.

Unlike many successful novelists, Lee had no interest in adapting her book for either stage or screen. However she welcomed its dramatic potential being realized by others. She approved both Horton Foote's script for the 1962 Oscar winning film starring Gregory Peck and Christopher Sergel's stage adaptation that is still frequently used (As in the 2011 production reviewed by Simon Saltzman in New Jersey and the one reviewed by Lizzie Loverige in London).

While Lee was still alive to sanction a new stage version by Aaron Sorkin, she died before his script was finalized and ready to go into production, Sorkin's changes to make the story more relevant for the present did create a much publicized legal controversy with her estate —a controversy that was settled in time to enable the launch to proceed at the Shubert Theater and become one of the biggest hits of the current Broadway season. Deservedly so!.

I still love Gregory Peck's Oscar-winning Atticus Finch and as soon as time permits, plan to watch it again on one of the streaming services where it's still available. I also think Harper Lee's novel deserved its Pulitzer. It's indeed a classic coming of age story with a beguiling main character — Mary Louise Finch, nicknamed Scout— to serve as the reader's conduit to life in a small Alabama town in 1935.

Fortunately, African-Americans have made great strides since Lee's Tom Robinson was convicted of a crime he didn't commit and killed before Atticus Finch could activate a retrial. Unfortunately, racial injustices and dangerous racist groups are still part of today's American social landscape. Thus any new dramatization of the iconic Lee novel calls for some drastic diddling with text and presentation. Sorkin has managed to do so dynamically, without any disrespect to either the novel or the movie that inform most of our memories.

Undoubtedly purists will miss some of the characters who have been eliminated. They'll also need to get used to the casting of adult actors (Celia Keenan-Bolger as Scout, Will Pullen as her older brother Jem and Gideon Glick as their pal and summer visitor to Mayburn Dill Harris) to play the three children; also Sorkin's focusing on Atticus as the character whose coming to realize" journey this now is.

And so, gone is the neighbor Miss Maudie who in the book was something of a one-person chorus endorsing Atticus's belief in the essential goodness of everyone. Since Atticus now speaks for himself, Miss Maudie is no longer needed to give voice to his comment about it being a sin to kill the titular mockingbird which unlike more predatory birds, had only one purpose: to make music for us to enjoy.

That symbolic quote is now distilled into Atticus's summation speech at Tom Robinson's trial. But the symbolism of not one but two songbirds — the mockinbird that gave the book its title and the Finch who provides the surname for Atticus and his children — has not gone missing. There are abundant other innovations for bringing Lee's story to vivid and contemporary dramatic life

Despite the updating, Sorkin and Director Bartlett Sher aren't aiming for a Ivan Van Hove-y approach. The major character and plot twists most theatergoers will be familiar with from the book and/or the Horton Foote scripted movie are all in place at the Shubert Theater — but with a distinctive shift in the timing and focus in which it all unfolds.

The setting is still the heavily racist town of Maycomb, Alabama in 1935, which means that Atticus Finch risks condemnation for defending a black man accused of raping a local white girl. Though Lee's plot revolved around that trial— its inevitable unjust outcome and its effect on Atticus and his children — she didn't rush her readers inside that courtroom.

Not so this Mockingbird!

We're taken into that volatile set-up immediately after the houselights dim and Scout appears in a preamble that establishes her as a continuing narrative presence. Sorkin's script as directed by Director Bartlett Sher travels back and forth between the courtroom drama and the play's more personal aspects.

With Atticus as our central character and thus now having to let go of his idealistic belief system, the challenges for doing so come mostly from his interactions with his children, especially his son. And, in keeping with our times, the two main black characters —the housekeeper Calpurnia (Tanya Richardson Jackson) and the unjustly accused Tom Robinson (Gbenga Akinnagbe) have been given a chance to have their say.

Probably this production's most drastic, and to my surprise and delight, most effective change from previous dramatizations is the casting of adult actors to play the Finch children(Celia Keenan-Bolger) and her brother Jem Finch(Will Pullen), and their friend Dill Harris (Gideon Glick). Though I usually find this off-putting and gimmicky, it's not a gimmick here. Thanks to the superb performances of the three actors this often risky casting really pays off beautifully.

Keenan-Bolger's perceptively narrating and physically amazing Scout adds a rich new dimension to this demanding role. She's likely to be the first actress to earn a Tony Best Actress nomination for portraying a character previously played by a child. (Actually 10-year-old Mary Badham who played Scout in the movie, did nab an Oscar nomination).

The one ghost most difficult for any new production to wrestle down is Gregory Peck's unforgettable Atticus Finch. But to once again prove that a really fine role doesn't belong only to the actor originating it (why else would we have so many Hamlets and Lears?), we have Jeff Daniels as a truly satisfying Atticus Finch. His Atticus perfectly blends moral goodness and paternal wisdom. Daniels is very much his own Atticus, less a formidable moral hero than a folksy guy trying to do the right thing but loathe to leave the comfort zone of his tolerant acceptance of his town's attitudes and customs.

Bartlett Sher also draws terrific performances from other members of the large cast populating the stage. Standouts include Frederick Weller as the scarily detestable bigot Bob Ewell, Erin Wilhelm as his abused daughter Mayella, Dakin Watkins as a delightfully humorous Judge Thomas, Danny Wolahan as Boo Radley. Also well defined and portrayed are minor characters like Ewell's more upscale moral counterpart, Mrs.Dubose (Phyllis Sommerville), and Link Deas (Heil Huff). While Atticus and the children are the play's heart and soul, the entire ensemble enhances this rich new evocation of the novel.

Mr. Bartlett's crafts team matches the excellence of his actors. Miriam Buether has created a most effective theatrical environment for the various locales. The tables and chairs being rolled on and off the stage for the courtroom scenes by the cast initially feels a little too loud and clunky. But it doesn't take long for Buether to turn the scene to scene shifts into wizardly effectiveness. Every scene is expertly lit by Jennifer Tipton, and the cast is aptly outfitted by veteran stage and screen costumer Ann Roth. The specially commissioned incidental music by Adam Guettel is played at opposite ends of the stage by by organist and music director Kimberly Grisby and guitarist Allen Tedder.

With their smartly restructured production, Sorkin, Sher and this cast have given Broadway theater goers an exciting, newly relevant experience— a meaty, grand entertainment not often offered at a time when theater offerings are dominated by minimally cast and staged 90 minute plays.

mockingbird Miscellany

The Atticus Finch Role Model.
The character of Atticus Finch was inspired by Lee's father, Amasa Coleman Lee, a newspaper editor and attorney. In 1919 he defended two black men who had been charged with murder. He lost the case and when the men were convicted, hanged and mutilated, he was so disillusioned that he abandoned criminal law.

More Real Life Role Models
Lee based Scout's friend Dill on her own childhood friend Truman Capote, or Truman Persons as he was known when they both grew up in Monroeville, Alabama (the geographical role model for Maybborn). The youngsters bonded through their love of reading and used to make up stories on Lee's father's old typewriter. The Capote/Dill connection clearly influenced Sorkin's characterization of Dill and Gideon Glick's portrayal to hint at his also being on a journey, in this case, as a gay man.

Lee and Capote remained friends into adulthood and Capote based his tomboy character in Other Voices, Other Rooms on Lee. However the friendship cooled after Lee helped him with extensive research for In Cold Blood and he only included her in the book's acknowledgement section. On the other hand, Lee loved Gregory Peck and his portrayal of Atticus and their friendship remained close and durable. In fact, Peck named his grandson for her.

What's in a Name Trivia
Boo Radley's real name is Arthur but the children call him "Boo" because to them he's as scary as a ghost. He probably was also inspired by a real member of a family that lived in a boarded up house near Lee's own home.

As for the children's referring to and addressing their father by his given name rather than Dad, this was during Lee's youth a common address used to show respect.

Historic Events That Influenced the Novel's Themes.
Among the actual events said to have inspired the novel's trial was the 1931 arrest of nine black teenagers from Alabama for supposedly raping two white women. While some of the boys were cleared and freed, the rest remained unjustly incarcerated. This case was also made into a successful musical (review).

Another incident during Lee's childhood involved a black man accused of raping a Monroeville white woman who was convicted and sentenced to death. The death sentence was changed to life in prison after letters declaring him innocent were printed in her father's newspaper. Finally, when Lee began her novel, a teenager named Emmett Till was murdered in Mississippi for flirting with a white woman.

Go Tell It to The Watchman, the "lost" Mockingbird
This unpublished early version of Mockingbird was published shortly before Lee's death. There was much controversy as to whether the lawyer who arranged it was being truthful in her claim that she had Lee's permission. At any rate, this very different and not especially well received prequel does point to the fact that there are many ways to tell this story.

Search CurtainUp in the box below Back to Curtainup Main Page

To Kill A Mockingbird
Written by Aaron Sorkin, based on Harper Lee ovel
Directed by Bartlett Sher
Cast (In order of appearance):Celia Keenan-Bolger (Scout Finch), Will Pullen ((Jem Finch), Gideon Glick (Dill Harris), Gbenga Akinnagbe (Tom Robinson),Stark Sands (Horace Gilmer),Danny McCarthy (Sheriff Heck Tate),Frederick Weller (Bob Ewell), Erin Wilhelm (Mayella Ewell), Latanya Richardson Jackson (Calpurnia),Jeff Daniels (Atticus Finch), Dakin Matthews (Judge Taylor),Liv Rooth (Miss Stephanie, also Dill's Mother), Phyllis Somerville (Mrs. Henry DuBose), Neal Huff (Link Deas),Danny Wolohan (Bo Radley)
Scenic Design by Miriam Buether
Costume Design by Ann Roth
Lighting Design by Jennifer Tipton
Sound Design by Scott Lehrer
Original incidental score by Adam Guettel, performed at stage left and right by music director Kimberly Grigsby (pump organ) and Allen Tedder (guitar).
Hair and Wig Design by Campbell Young Associates
roduction Stage Manager: J. Jason Daunter
Stage Manager: Rachel Zack
Running Time: 2 hours and 35 minutes, with one intermission.
Shubert Theatre 225 West 44th Street
From 11/01/18; opening 12/13/18
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer on 1/15/19g

Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of To Kill a Mockingbird
  • I disagree with the review of To Kill a Mockingbird
  • The review made me eager to see To Kill a Mockingbird
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted at to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter

©Copyright 2018, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from