The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings

A CurtainUp Review
Significant Other On Broadway

It's not surprising that Joshua Harmon's updated version of the once old-fashioned and new romantic comedy has moved to Broadway without losing its charm, humor and poignancy. After all, it's still got Gideon Glick as the delightful almost-30-and still without a significant other in sight. Also still on board is Barbara Barrie is still on board as as his grandma on the other end of life's seesaw. Though Vanessa, onf of Jason's three altar bound girl friends is new to the cast, she fits in just fine. The Booth is of course bigger than the Laura Pels Theater where Significant Other premiered, but director Trip Cullman and his team have seen to it that everything fits right into its new home.

Since the only way the show has changed is that Glick has had a chance to deepen his character to be even more endearing. Ditto for the other actors playing the significant others that are in his life. I'm therefore reposting a very slightly updated original review and with the current production notes.

I know life is supposed to be this great mystery, but I actually think it's pretty simple: find someone to go through it with. That's it. That's the, whatever, the secret.—Jordan

You make it sound so easy.—Lauren

No that's the hardest part. Walking around knowing what the point is, but not being able to live it, and not knowing how to get it, or if I ever even will — Jordan
Gideon Glick & Lindsay Mendez (Photo: Joan Marcus)
Joshua Harmon's first play, Bad Jews, began life at the Black Box venue the Roundabout created to make theater more appealing and affordable for the millenial generation. That target audience did indeed love it, but so did older audience memberss when it moved to the theater's larger larger space. Bad Jews turned out to please lots of other theatergoers in its many subsequent productions.

No wonder the Roundabout opened Significant Other right in the larger Laura Pels theater. Harmon once again proved himself to be a wonderful wordsmith and astute chronicler of the quandaries faced by the contemporary young adults.

Though Roundabout's main subscribers are older than Harmon's foursome of singles who suddenly find themselves at that almost thirty turn in the bumpy road of life, they have children and grandchildren whose romantic missteps and joys help anyone of any age relate to Mr. Harmon's significantly funny and poignant new play .

Basically this is an old-fashioned romantic comedy, but with new-fangled details and a leading character who's gay. It's also a story about friendship as a form of family in which you try to accept and keep loving each other even as your lives send you on different paths.

The play follows the lives of a quartet of 29-year-olds who have been close friends since college. Three are women, one is a gay man. As in Wendy Wasserstein's Isn't It Romantic (a quote from which is used to introduce Harmon's script), all want to be amazing and keep sharing each others amazing lives. All have jobs — Kiki and Jordan (Sas Goldberg and Gideon Glick) work for a large advertising agency, Vanessa (Carra Patterson- Rebecca Naomi Jones on Broadway) is an editor at a book publishing office, Laura (Lindsay Mendez) is a teacher.

However, it's not their jobs but the way the actors present their characters that individualizes each. The focus here isn't on their careers but on their romantic lives.

The women all manage to pass that critical almost-30 point with their dream of love fulfilled. What's more, all decide to celebrate their marriages with traditional wedding rituals like bachelorette parties and walking down the aisle in white gowns with bridesmaids.

Kiki is first to the altar, visibly pregnant. By the time Laura, with whom Jordan was especially close and compatible, finds her true love, the neurotic but likeable Jordan is the always a bridesmaid never a bride character in this story.

This is a virtuoso performance by Glick. He's on stage throughout, balancing self-absorption and immaturity with vulnerability and charm.

Jordan does have two romances, both of which go nowhere. The first traces an obsessive infatuation with a hunky co-worker, Will (John Behlmann, differentiating this as well as two other male characters so smoothly that you can hardly tell it's the same actor). There's also a rekindled relationship with Gideon (Luke Smith, another adept triple role player). Watching Jordan try to connect with Will makes us (if not Jordan) see that if he would only be more self-assured and realistically grown-up (like his female friends), he too could indeed find a significant other.

Before we can even hope that Jordan will have his own happy ending, there are the three weddings to exacerbate his growing certainty that he'll never find someone to go through life with. ("I'm twenty-nine years old and no one has ever told me they love me.") His mounting despair is heightened by his feeling less important to the friends who have been his family. Ths comes to a head with a long and angry rant before Laura's wedding. Like a break out number in a musical, that rant also happens to be a show stopping turn for Glick.

Someone who does love Jordan very much and tells him so is his grandmother Helene Berman (a compellingly low key performance by Barbara Barrie). She's a smart and meaningful addition to the play.

Jordan visits grandma often to deliver her medicines and to find some answers to his life in her family remembrances. He and grandma are symbolic bookends of two crucial life stages: He's painfully stumbling into a stage of adulthod where he knows what the point of a meaningful life is for him but still doesn't know how to get it. She, on the other hand, did manage to have a full and meaningful life but knows that she can't have it back. To her Jordan may be a late starter in the happiness game, but she assures him he will get to the next chapter.

If there weren't already a famous movie with a similar name, Harmon might have named this Three Weddings and a Funeral. The funeral in this case symbolizes how Jordan views the effect of his favorite friend Laura's wedding on their friendship.

At any rate, the weddings, and all the events throughout the year during which they take place are staged with great imagination and style. by Trip Cullman and set designer Mark Wendland have actualized Harmon's stage direction: "the scenes should bleed into each other. Because love bleeds." Thus we jump from Jordan's office, to his and Laura's apartment, to several interchanges with Vanessa at MOMA, to grandma Berman's apartment and the various wedding-related events — all without blackouts fussy prop movememts. It's all one scene with the actors movements and costume changes and lighting(by Kaye Voyce and Japhy Weidemann) to keep us clear as to where we are. Choreographer Sam Pinkleton contributes to the fun with a lively big dance at each of the weddings.

I do have one significant quibble. Mixed up as he is, it is a stretch to believe that Jordan's only social contacts are those three women and his grandmother. What about his parents? They're alive since they're paying for grandma's cleaning woman. No mention of a fraught relationship with them or any siblings. Given the script's introductory quote from Wendi Wasserstein's Isn't It Romantic, it's also just a bit odd for all three of these women to consider a white wedding with all the trimmings the epitome of "amazing." But then, I also said this was an old-fashioned romantic comedy — and that genre never insisted that everything should make perfect sense.

Search CurtainUp in the box below Back to Curtainup Main Page

Significant Other by Joshua Harmon
Directed by Trip Cullman
Cast: Barbara Barrie (Helene), John Behlmann (Will/Conrad/Tony), Sas Goldberg (Kiki), Gideon Glick (Jordan), Lindsay Mendez (Laura), Rebecca Naomi Jones (Vanessa) and Luke Smith (Gideon/Evan/Roger)
Sets: Mark Wendland
Lighting: Japhy Weideman
Costumes: Kaye Voyce
Sound: Daniel Kluger
Choreography: Sam Pinkleton
Stage Manager: Samantha Watson Running Time:2 hours and 15 minutes, including intermission
Booth Theatre, 222 West 45th Street between Broadway and 8th Avenue
From 2/14/17; opening 3/02/17; closing 7/02/17 -- closing moved up, closing 4/23/17
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer

Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C
  • I agree with the review of Significant Other on Broadway
  • I disagree with the review of Significant Other on Broadway
  • The review made me eager to see Significant Other on Brodway
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted at href="http://www.facebook Children under the age of 4 are not permitted in the theatre. First Preview Date Opening Date On Sale Through February 14, 2017 .com/home.php?ref=home#/profile.php?id=641485481"> Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter

©Copyright 2016, 2017 Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from