Bat Boy, a CurtainUp review CurtainUp

The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings





Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants









Free Updates
Writing for Us
A CurtainUp Review
Bat Boy

Bat Boy Wings It To London
by Lizzie Loveridge

Three and a half years after New York, Bat Boy The Musical comes to the Shaftesbury in London in a very different production from the American original but with its star intact, the affecting Deven May as the curious genetically deviant hero. It takes the humanity of this mutant to demonstrate the show's serious message, the prejudice and intolerance of men towards someone or something they do not understand. This is no travelogue for West Virginia but a condemnation of rural ignorance.

Mark Wing-Davey has directed with some of the chorus cross dressing for no particular purpose, not to boost the number of either men or women, but maybe to increase the zany quotient. I liked Madeline Herbert's design very much with its cartoon like trees and houses drawn in neon strip outline. The first half of the musical is frankly disappointing but stay until after the interval when it peps up and becomes much more fun. The happy clappy revivalist meeting inevitably livens up the musical and the scene in the forest which has animals mating, and may make the show unsuitable for the under thirteens, sees it go over the top in a celebration of fecundity for fornicating furries.

Of the songs, the new "Mine, All Mine" is a showstopper, a tuneful ballad. Some of the lyrics are very good indeed, little gems of wit that made me smile again and again, such as we might expect from Keythe Farley and Brian Fleming, authors of the story and book, and two of the creators of The Rugrats.I can identify with "Please let me have my own way, I've had a really rough day" from Shelley. Deven May conveys the boy with bat like characteristics very well indeed, he is a charming innocent in a cruel world and Rebecca Vere as Meredith Parker cares for him convincingly.

The final racy denouement is excellent and a taste of what the show could have been if this standard could have been maintained throughout. The Shaftesbury is very much off the beaten tourist track and tends not to get passing trade, so unless Bat Boy The Musical gathers a cult audience, I fear it will not linger. The newspaper critics do sometimes get it wrong, see their first response to the very successful We Will Rock You, but they have been less kind to Bat Boy than the West Virginians portrayed in the musical.

Bat Boy The Musical
Music and Lyrics by Laurence O'Keefe
Story and Book by Keythe Farley and Brian Flemming
Directed by Mark Wing-Davey

Starring: Deven May
With: Rebecca Vere, John Barr, Emma Williams, Andrew Bolton, Gareth Richards, Julie Jupp, Robyn Isaac, Maurey Richards, David Beckford, Robert Archibald, Tim Driesen, Thomas Goodridge, Rachel Lynes, Wyn Moss, Amanda Villamayor
Choreographer: Lynne Page
Designer: Madeline Herbert
Musical Director: Iain Vince-Gatt
Lighting Designer: Tony Simpson
Sound: Mike Walker
Projection Designer: Mark Logue
Running time: Two hours twenty minutes with one interval
Box Office: 020 7379 599
Booking to 30th October 2004.
Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge based on 8th September 2004 performance at the Shaftesbury Theatre, Shaftesbury Avenue, London WC2 (Tube/Rail: )

Musical Numbers
Act One
  • Hold Me, Bat Boy (prologue)/ Full Company
  • Christian Charity/ Sheriff, Meredith, Shelley
  • Hey Freak / Shelley, Meredith, Rick
  • A Home for You/ Meredith
  • Another Dead Cow/ Bud, Ned, Roy, Lorraine, Maggie, Townsfolk
  • Dance With Me Darling/ Dr Parker Mrs Taylor's Lullaby/ Mrs. Taylor, Rick, Ron, Ruthie
  • Show You a Thing or Two/ Bat Boy, Meredith, Shelley, Dr Parker
  • Christian Charity/ (Reprise) Sheriff, Parker, Townsfolk
  • A Home for You (Reprise) / Bat Boy
  • Comfort and Joy/ Full Company
Act Two
  • A Joyful Noise/ Rev. Hightower, The Congregation
  • Let Me Walk Among You/ Bat Boy
  • Hey Freak (Reprise)/ Shelley, Meredith, Rick
  • Three Bedroom House / Meredith, Shelley
  • Children, Children/ King of the Forest, Company
  • More Blood/Kill The Bat Boy/ Dr Parker, Townsfolk
  • Mine All Mine/ Shelley, Bat Boy
  • Apology to a Cow/ Bat Boy

  • Revelations/ Meredith, Dr Parker, Parents, Doctor
  • I Imagine You're Upset (Finale)/ Full Company
  • Hold Me, Bat Boy" (Reprise)/ Full Company
Deven May & Kerry Butler
Deven May & Kerry Butler
(Photo: Joan Marcus)
Elyse Sommer's New York Review-

Move over Rocky Horror Show and make room for Bat Boy the spunky, spoofy high energy musical that's just settled in at the Union Square Theatre. It's a lampoon salad that tosses together sendups of popular "B" horror movies and enough easily recognizable plays and musicals to rival Forbidden Broadway.

Bat Boy also makes musical history by pioneering the super market tabloid as libretto source material. The "true" story of the half-boy -half bat found in a cave was a major scoop of the early 90s for that purveyor of all the news that's likely to boost circulation, Weekly World News.

While the program acknowledges this unlikely source above the actors' credits, it's the creative team listed above paper's credit -- writers Keythe Farley and Brian Flemming and composer-lyricist Laurence O'Keefe-- who have elevated the unlikely tale from its low-brow origins into a wacky but witty, cult-in-the-making show. And it's Deven May's truly remarkable portrayal of the Bat Boy that transforms the pointy-eared, snaggle-toothed freak into an endearing hero. His semi-humanoid reflects the influence of Jerry Lewis and also brings to mind Janie Dee's enchanting "actoid" in last season's non-musical hit, Comic Potential. and his physical movements. This last is not to say this is a show likely to go over with more than a sprinkling of the conventional Manhattan Theater Club subscribers who heartily embraced the Ayckbourn comedy. Its appeal is to the Rocky Horror Show enthusiasts and those who have made Bat Boy's neighbor, De La Guarda, something of an institution

Bat Boy is not a big musical. There are just nine performers besides May, all zooming in and out of roles like -- well, like bats out of hell. These versatile performers represent the narrow-minded inhabitants of the small West Virginia town of Hope Falls, an erstwhile coal mining town whose citizens have tried to retool themselves as cattle rangers. This is an unlikely undeavor given the town's mountainous geography (which lends metaphorical signifance to its name), but it does provide local adventurers with plenty of caves to explore.

It is in one of Hope Falls' caves that the mutant creature is discovered. His biting one of the locals, Ruthie (Daria Hardeman), earns him the hostility of her brother Rick (Doug Storm). It also brings on the sheriff (Richard Pruitt) who delivers Bat Boy to the home of the local veterinarian Thomas Parker (Sean McCourt).

Doctor Parker's wife Meredith (Kaitlin Hopkins who taps into the humor of her role without ever overacting and also has a true musical star's voice) takes the frightened creature under her maternal wing and, aided by some BBC language tapes and her teenaged daughter Shelley (Kerry Butler, another solid performer with a soaring voice), transforms him into a proper young man named Edgar. After a delightfully choreographed hilarious Fair Lady style tutorial, "Show You a Thing Or Two", ("A bit more schooling; a lot less drooling," from the teachers and a gleeful "I think I've got it!" from the batty humanoid) Edgar is no longer just a blend of bat and boy but also of Boris Karloff and Eliza Doolittle. But though he now talks like a boy and looks like a boy (well, just about), and has a boy's yearnings to be accepted -- his touching "Let Me Walk Among You" in the second act tries to appeal to the bat inside all the townspeople-- his taste buds are still those of a bat. He prefers blood to bread, broccoli or beef. Dr. Parker, who turns out to be the villain of the piece, is the only one who kows Edgar's dangerous little secret -- at least until the plot takes further twists and turns and winds down to its fantastical and fatal conclusion.

Laurence O'Keefe's peppy and melodic pop-rock score is played by a five piece combo tucked away at the side of the stage. The single unit, double-tiered set by Robert Hoover and Bryan Johnson evokes an appropriate sense of eeriness and easily and with minimal fuss converts into the various locations in which the comi-tragic saga unfolds (its emphasis by director Scott Schwartz, steadfastly on the comic): a dark, deep cave, the Parker family's living room, a slaughter house, a revival meeting tent (conducted with verve by the outstanding Trent Armand Kendall who is also a riot as the bat-bitten Ruthie's mother), the woods and the town's houses.

If Bat Boy could be said to have an anthem song, it's probably "Hold Me Bat Boy" which opens and closes the show. There are a number of others which should make for the likelihood of a popular CD, though there are also a number of less than memorable ones. "Children Children" which propels a Lion King spoof isn't as clever as "Show You a Thing Or Two" but it brought down the house with the laughter drowning out most of the lyrics.

With all these wonderfully weird goings on, and given that co-author Keythe Farley has written for Rugrats, this is a show that's likely to appeal to the whole family (provided the kids are at least nine or ten). On the other hand, parents who think some of the adult stuff might just go over the kids' head might bear in mind one ten-year old's reply to a man who during intermission asked him if he was having a good time, "sure-- and I know what's going on!"

If Bat Boy lives up to its promise as cult hit, it wouldn't be too surprising for the Weekly World News' other mega hit story, "Elvis Is Alive", became Elvis Is Alive: The Musical. If you want to check out some of the tunes before investing in a ticket, check this website

The Rocky Horror Show
Comic Potential
De La Guarda
Forbidden Broadway 2001;
The Lion King

Story and book by Keythe Farley and Brian Flemming
Music and lyrics by Laurence O'Keefe by
Directed by Scott Schwartz
Cast: Deven May as the Bat Boy; also Kerry Butler, Kathy Brier, Daria Hardeman, Sean McCourt, Kaitlin Hopkins, Trent Armand Kendall, Jim Price, Richard Pruitt and Doug Storm.
Set Design: Richard Hoover and Bryan Johnson
Lighting Design: Howell Binkley
Costume Design: Fabio Toblini
Sound Design Sunjil Rajan
Musical Director (and pianist) . Alex Lacamoire
Running Time: 2 hours and 15 minutes, including intermission
Union Square Theatre, 100 E. 17th St, 307-4100

Reviewed by Elyse Sommer based on 3/22/01 performance

Musical Numbers
Act One
  • Hold Me, Bat Boy (prologue)/ Full Company
  • Christian Charity/ Sheriff, Meredith, Shelley
  • Another Dead Cow Townsfolk
  • Ugly Boy / Shelley
  • Watcha Wanna Do?/ Rick, Shelley
  • A Home for You/ Meredith, Bat Boy
  • Dance With Me, Darling / Parker
  • Ruthie’s Lullaby/ Mrs. Taylor
  • Show You a Thing or Two/ Full Company
  • Christian Charity/ (Reprise) Sheriff, Parker, Townsfolk
  • A Home for You (Reprise) / Bat Boy
  • Comfort and Joy/ Full Company
Act Two
  • A Joyful Noise/ Rev. Hightower, The Congregation
  • Three Bedroom House / Meredith, Shelley
  • Children, Children/ King of the Forest, Company
  • More Blood/ Parker
  • Inside Your Heart/ Shelley, Bat Boy
  • Apology to a Cow/ Bat Boy

  • I Imagine You’re Upset (Finale)/ Full Company
  • Hold Me, Bat Boy” (Reprise)/ Full Company
©Copyright 2004, Elyse Sommer, CurtainUp.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from