The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings








Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
Writing for Us

A CurtainUp London London Review
Dealer's Choice
Another Look at Dealer's Choice by Charlotte Loveridge

This much deserved West End transfer boasts the same excellent cast and finely-nuanced direction, both of which bring out in full the comedy of Patrick Marber’s exemplary play. Although losing a little of the intimacy of the Menier’s auditorium in its new home the Trafalgar Studios, this production has enough style, engaging characters and pure fun to continue its reign of sensation.

Sam West’s influence is evidenced by intelligent control and subtlety within the characters’ strong personalities. He creates a sense of a poker-game netherworld, with an intense macho atmosphere where men are compelled to play. Shifting power dynamics of control, success and shame all contribute to this, and tense father-son relations (real and surrogate) are strained, tested and ultimately proved.

The all-too-human characters inhabiting this sphere, however, are brimming with likeability and humour. Within the well-chosen cast, Steven Wight continues to impress as the irrepressible Mugsie, while Malcolm Sinclair is suitably "granite" as father and manager, Steven, Samuel Barnett is sympathetic as Carl the weak, compulsive debt-ee and Roger Lloyd Pack convincingly plays the dry yet desperate professional Ash.

This fine production demonstrates just what a great playwright Patrick Marber is. Although written twelve years ago and before the phenomenon of online poker took over the world, Marber’s first play has lost none of its edge or humour. This is a sleek production which does full justice to a play full of wit and humanity.

Cast and credits as for the Menier
Booking to 29th March 2008 at the Trafalgar Studios One
Box Office: 0870 060 6632
Re-reviewed by Charlotte Loveridge on 11th December at Trafalgar Studios One, Whitehall, London SW1 (Rail/Tube: Charing Cross, Embankment)

Original review by by Lizzie Loveridge

It's about never saying die even when you are dead.— Mugsy
Dealer's Choice
Stephen Wight as Mugsy and Roger Lloyd Pack as Ash. (Photo: Nobby Clark)
This was Patrick Marber's first play. It was the first time a writer was allowed to direct his own first play at the National Theatre and Patrick Marber was the first playwright since Tom Stoppard to have his debut play produced at the National. All this was twelve years ago in 1995. In a week when the headlines told us that Britain is spending £10 billion a year on gambling, this play about poker and gambling and addiction is very pertinent. It's being produced at the tiny Menier Chocolate Factory Theatre which is fast developing as one to watch (a couple of stunning musical revivals have transferred to the West End and their Sondheim success Sunday in the Park with George is on its way to Broadway for 2008).

Seeing Dealer's Choice for the first time and long having been a fan of Closer, my only regret is that Marber hasn't written anything more recently for the stage. I know he has been involved in some adaptations and some film scripting, but his original writing for theatre is so witty and incisive that I hope he may be inspired by theatre again.

The first act is set in the kitchen of a restaurant in London. All the staff are anticipating the weekly poker game held in the basement after the last diner has left the restaurant. The group are threatened with the loss of three of their regular players. One is at his father's funeral, another, Sweeney the chef (Ross Boatman) can't afford it and needs the money to keep his promise to take out his daughter the next day and the restaurant owner's son, Carl (Samuel Barnett) says he hasn't the money. Mugsy, the waiter (Stephen Wight) is looking forward to the game and hoping to raise £1000 to convert some unusual premises in the Mile End Road into a restaurant of his own. Stephen, the restauranteur (Malcolm Sinclair) is determined to hold the card game. His son Carl is in debt to a professional poker player Ash (Roger Lloyd Pack) and introducing Ash to the weekly game may get them both out of a hole. The second act is set in the basement round the card game. Frankie (Jay Simpson) the wine waiter dreams of going to Vegas and cleaning up on the professional poker circuit. No-one can resist even the simplest of bets — the toss you for it, heads or tails, the all or nothing risk.

True Dealer's Choice is about the addiction to the game but it is also about fathers and sons and power. The relationship between Carl and his father Stephen is strained to breaking point. Mugsy, the East End lad is so straightforward that Stephen compares him with expensively educated Carl who tries to hide his gambling habit from his father. Ash has taught Carl how to play and funded his first year and so is almost fatherly towards him. Marber says that when he wrote it, it was from the perspective of the difficulty of the son, "now it strikes him as being about the complexity of being a father." Interesting is it not, how even the playwright's latest experiences can change the pitch of his own play?

Poker seems to be largely a male pursuit (poker players like Victoria Coren are the exception rather than the rule) and this is an all male cast. The game promises not just a game of cards, a chance to win or lose but also the camaraderie of male companionship. When Mugsy loses his money, Carl knows that paying back the money he owes him will keep Mugsy in the game and the game going. It seems that everyone will stay until they have lost all they have. By the end of the game, these players haven't just lost their stake, they have lost their dreams as well.

The performances are absolutely first class. Simon Wight as the cheeky chappy Cockney is a breath of fresh air. Even during the serious game he is animated and takes us on a roller coaster of win lose emotion and comedy wearing his lucky, Hawaiian shirt which is as loud as his personality. Ross Boatman is a RADA trained actor and incidentally one of the top five professional poker players in the country as the sad, tortured Sweeney. But I was particularly taken by Roger Lloyd Pack's jaded, deadpan Ash. His timing, artfully slow with long pauses as he disguises his true identity is masterly. He is not afraid to let the joke play very slowly and then to make the switch from high comedy to full tragedy. Malcolm Sinclair has the least sympathetic character and I was shocked by the way Stephen manipulates his son into agreeing to play. "If you don't play, I don't see you." The ultimate gamble — a terrible blackmail — of a desperate man.

The sets work well. The working restaurant kitchen has a few tables to the fore of the stage laid for dinner and where Ash can sit as a diner. The second half focuses on the green baize. In between scenes is thrilling, rhythmic drumming music which adds to the excitement and anticipation.

But the absolutely best thing about Dealer's Choice is Marber's brilliant script. Gems like "Some can stand the heat, others stay in the kitchen" are worthy of Oscar Wilde. I liked the scene where Carl and Stephen argue and simultaneously, so do, slightly upstage, Sweeney and Frankie. Enter Mugsy whom they all turn on. The repartee between Mugsy and Stephen is very, very funny and the tension between Carl and Stephen is real and painful. When Carl says to his father, "Why does it have to be so emotional? Why can't it be like you're a bank and I'm a customer?" we understand why the parent may be annoyed. It says in the programme notes that the show's director, Sam West used to play poker with Patrick Marber. I expect that actors can be rather good at poker because they can teach their bodies to deceive. This excellent production of a smashing play deserves a full house every night.

Note: Tickets are now on sale for the Menier's Christmas production of La Cage Aux Folles which will star Douglas Hodge and Philip Quast. The show previews from November 23rd and some shows are sold out already.

Written by Patrick Marber
Directed by Samuel West

Starring: Roger Lloyd Pack, Malcolm Sinclair, Stephen Wight
With: Ross Boatman, Jay Simpson, Samuel Barnett
Design: Tom Piper
Lighting: Neil Austin
Sound: Gareth Owen
Composer: Terry Davies
Running time: Two hours 25 minutes with one interval
Box Office: 020 7907 7060
Booking to 17th November 2007
Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge based on 4th October 2007 performance at the Menier Chocolate Factory Theatre, 51/53 Southwark Street London SE1 (Rail/Tube: London Bridge)

London Theatre Walks

Peter Ackroyd's  History of London: The Biography

London Sketchbook

tales from shakespeare
Retold by Tina Packer of Shakespeare & Co.
Click image to buy.
Our Review

©Copyright 2007, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from