The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings






New Jersey



A CurtainUp Review
Golden Boy of the Blue Ridge
Put the gun down and step away from the 'shine'—J.M.
Golden Boy of the Blue Ridge
Carol Hickey, Mark Modzingo, and Victoria Huston-Elem in Golden Boy of the Blue Ridge (Photo: Gerry Goodstein)
From an edgy, punk-rock riff on The Bacchae (The Rockae) to a stunning interpretation of As You Like It set in feudal Japan (Honor), the prolific Prospect Theater Company continues to produce unexpected, ambitious new works. Now, with Golden Boy of the Blue Ridge—an adaptation of J.M. Synge's The Playboy of the Western World— the company adds a bluegrass tuner to its ever-expanding musical canon. A sweet, simple fable of an unlikely and rather unremarkable love triangle, Golden Boy shimmers thanks to its engaging, on-stage bluegrass band and the grit and gusto of its capable cast.

To the foreboding strums of a guitar, a mysterious man named Clayton appears one day at the home of Maggie and her father, J.M. Filthy and disheveled, Clayton announces that he is on the run after killing his father with a shovel. Even more mysteriously, J.M. decides that Clayton is just the person to employ as his new hired man to look out for Maggie, who reluctantly plans to wed the bumbling Luther in two days. But as Clayton scrubs the dirt from his face, it's clear that there is something about him that is irresistible—something otherworldly, but also, judging from the swoons of the neighbor women, something to do with the handsome image reflected back in Maggie's hand mirror.

The standoffish Maggie initially resists Clayton's attentions, but soon begins to wonder if he is the man she always dreamed would appear to take her away. Of course, Clayton's past eventually catches up with him in a raucous fashion, but not before he upends the daily routine of the small community.

Bookwriter Cara Reichel (who also directs) has filled the dialogue with a forced hill country vernacular that includes such twisty turns of phrase as "You ain't humbuggin' me" and "You look like death eating a cracker." I lost count of the number of times I heard a character say "a'feared." But although these colorful expressions often seem contrived when they arise in plain speech, in song they spring to believable life. Even the hackneyed description "brambles in her heart" sounds right, somehow, when sung in Clayton and Maggie's love duet, which features the lovely lyric "there's more to me I only see with you."

With its rustic, homespun charms, Golden Boy's man-disrupts-life-of-stoic-woman plot is a familiar one. Last year's Broadway revival of 110 in the Shade, for example, a musical adaptation of the play The Rainmaker, also chronicled the change that jolts through a town when a strapping stranger appears from the wilderness. What sets Golden Boy apart are its unique, irresistible songs; composer Peter Mills has created an enigmatic, evocative score that tells the story better than any dialogue could.

A few songs wear out their welcome—early on, with the music meandering along at a snail's pace as it teases out Clayton's story in bits and pieces. But when band members Dennis Keefe (bass), Matthew Dure (guitar), and Mike Rosengarten (banjo and mandolin) take center stage, donning aprons to sing about their unrequited love for "A Wanted Man," the story kicks into gear as they accompany themselves in this perky, plucky song. The trio pop into the action at various moments, an excellent choice that further synthesizes the music and the story. Music director Eli Zoller leads the fantastic 5-member band, which also features Melody Allegra Berger on the fiddle. In fact, I overheard many audience members murmuring that they wished they could purchase a CD of the music to take with them—here's hoping this score might be preserved through a recording at some point in the future.

Tate R. Burmeister's rustic, wood-planked set effectively summons up the meager home of Maggie and her father. It's a cozy stage, but Reichel makes the most of the space, particularly during a rousing chase scene, in which characters catapult themselves through a surprising array of nooks and crannies.

The show opens with the rousing "Way Out Back and Beyond," which creates a foreboding atmosphere, most potently through Evan Purcell's ominous lighting, which creates striking silhouettes behind the actors. The characters move through a series of pantomimes that foreshadow the story, and the choreography, with its percussive stomping, resembles an aggressive square dance. This tempestuous tone evaporates after the powerful opening, fading into a more restrained mood, and the performers offer a similarly uneven batch of acting approaches. Dan Sharkey gives a persuasive but steadfastly over-the-top performance as J.M., complete with bulging eyes and sputtering surliness. As Leroy, the ghost of Clayton's past, Scott Wakefield offers a similarly outsize (but convincing) characterization.

On the more realistic end, Carol Hickey strikes the perfect balance of silliness and simplicity as neighborhood gossip Hazel. As the lightweight Luther, Jeff Edgerton provides much of the show's physical comedy and shows a gift for slapstick humor—he also dances superbly (and defensively) to prove himself worthy of Maggie.

Mark Mozingo sings sweetly as tortured bad-boy Clayton, but it's Victoria Huston-Elem's wonderfully grounded performance as Maggie that is the heart of the production. She brings such depth to her performance that you wish there were more there for her to act. Much of Maggie's background is a murky mystery, but, as in the best achy melodies, you know there's much more beneath the surface than meets the ear. Her striking delivery of the plaintive ballad "Golden Boy" is one of the show's loveliest moments.

If the lyric "I was born lonesome as a moon at dawn" speaks to you, you're going to love Golden Boy of the Blue Ridge. There's something immediately engaging about the shivering guitar chords and casual camaraderie of this music, and although there's ultimately not much of a story to tell, in this production, the music effectively becomes its own story. And begs the question: What will the Prospect Theater Company come up with next?

Golden Boy of the Blue Ridge
Based on J.M. Synge's Playboy of the Western World
Book & Lyrics by Cara Reichel
Music & Lyrics by Peter Mills
Directed by Cara Reichel
Music Direction by Eli Zoller
Cast: Melody Allegra Berger (Winnie/Walt/Fiddle), Matthew Dure (Eunice/Ed/Guitar), Jeff Edgerton (Luther), Carol Hickey (Hazel), Victoria Huston-Elem (Maggie), Dennis Michael Keefe (Nelly/Newton/Bass), Mark Mozingo (Clayton), Mike Rosengarten (Sara/Sean/Banjo & Mandolin), Dan Sharkey (J.M.), and Scott Wakefield (Leroy)
Scenic & Properties Design: Tate R. Burmeister
Costume Design: Sidney Shannon
Lighting Design: Evan Purcell
Sound Design: Daniel Erdberg
Fight Choreography by Jacob Grigolia-Rosenbaum
Running Time: 2 hours, one intermission
Prospect Theater Company at 59E59 Theaters, 59 East 59th Street (212) 279-4200
Performances: Tuesday at 7:15pm, Wednesday-Saturday at 8:15pm, Sunday at 3:15pm.
From 4/11/09; opening 4/17/09; closes 5/3/09
Review by Amy Krivohlavek based on performance 4/17/09
Musical Numbers
Act One
  • Way Out Back and Beyond/Company
  • The Right Man for the Job/Clayton, Maggie, J.M. & The Boys
  • Never Afeard Again/Clayton
  • Little Log Cabin/Hazel, Maggie
  • A Wanted Man/The Girls
  • Twice-Told Tale/Clayton
  • Golden Boy/Maggie and The Girls
  • First-Class Ticket/Luther, Hazel, and the Band
  • Nowhere Near to Done/Leroy and Company
Act Two
  • Grist for the Mill/Winnie, Hazel, and The Boys
  • A Wanted Man (Reprise)/Company
  • That Ain't Him/Hazel, Leroy
  • More to Me/Clayton, Maggie
  • Inlaws and Outlaws/J.M., Luther, Maggie
  • Sixes and Sevens/The Band
  • West of Where I Been/Clayton
  • Golden Boy (Reprise)/Company
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Golden Boy of the Blue Ridge
  • I disagree with the review of Golden Boy of the Blue Ridge
  • The review made me eager to see Golden Boy of the Blue Ridge
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

You can also contact us at Curtainup at Facebook or Curtainup at Twitter
Try for great seats to
Jersey Boys
The Little Mermaid
Lion King
Shrek The Musical

South Pacific  Revival
South Pacific

In the Heights
In the Heights

Playbill 2007-08 Yearbook

Leonard Maltin's Classic Movie Guide
Leonard Maltin's 2008 Movie Guide


©Copyright 2009, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from