The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings







Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review
In Conflict

I wanted to know what was going on in Iraq, and I wanted to know what was going on with the people that I believed were going to tell the truth; and that's the soldiers, because they're the ones who are actually there.
— Yvonne Latty, in the first of numerous intermittent video clips in which she sets the tone for the soldiers' accounts of their Iraq experience in Douglas C. Wager's stage adaptation of her book, In Conflict.
 In Conflict
Some of the In Conflict cast members (Photo: Ryan S. Brandenberg)
General William Tecumseh Sherman, who led the Northern army during the Civil War, knew what he was talking about when he famously declared "War is hell." More than a century later, television nes has brought war right into our living rooms Still, the hell experienced by those not just watching brief snippets of war scenes and listening to endless pro and con discussions is indescribable. But that doesn't stop the inevitable bring flood of books, articles, films and plays that try to describe what it's like. The Iraq War has been no exception.

Three plays seen during the last couple of weeks have taken different approaches: In Lady (Lady), Craig Wright views the issues of the war through a darkly comic and very small lens, his dramatic device for tackling the subject of the Iraq war is a hunting reunion of three middle-aged friends. Michael Weller's Beast (review) wraps an angry outcry about the lack of respect and support given to Iraq's mentally and physically wounded into the framework of a surreal road trip by two badly maimed veterans.

In Conflict is not fiction but a documentary forged from Yvonne Latty's published interviews with dozens of men and women who did tours of duty in Iraq. Though the words are spoken by actors, these aren't invented characters, but real flesh and blood, ordinary soldiers. Some, like the two men in the Weller play, have lost limbs. Many suffer in one way or another from post-traumatic stress, with one soldier who came home physically intact nevertheless envisioning himself as a mental amputee ("Canít nobody give me a prosthetic mind"} The words they speak are their own, not prettied up by Ms. Latty and so In Conflict is the kind of political theater that relies more on the authenticity of its presentation than star power (think Guantanomo and The Exonerated).

Unlike another journalist, George Packer, who adapted his own New Yorker article Betrayed for The Culture Project, Yvonne Latty left it to Douglas C. Wager, the artistic director of the Temple University Theater, to make her book of interviews with soldiers who served in Iraq stageworthy. Wager has remained true to Latty's objective in writing her book: to give voice to the ordinary soldiers who are more often than not pre-empted from the news by the men who sent them to Iraq. However, he has given each soldier's story its own dramatic framework and seen to it that the presentation overall connects the individual interviews into a cohesive stage portrait. To do so, he interspersee the interview accounts with some group sequences like marine training sessions, and an anti-war rally led by Kelly Dougherty, who joined the National Guard for college tuition and after being involuntarily deployed with the military police unit to Baghdad and became Executive Director of Iraq Veterans Against the War.

The dramatic aura is established with limited but quite effective stagecraft: Set designer Andrew Laine's revolving panels are dynamically lit by J. Dominic Chacon. Christopher Cappello and Paul Winnick add propulsive sound design. Warren Bass's video design allows Miss Latty to be on hand to set the scene for some of the interviews but it's never allowed to take over from the men and women on stage.

What gives these often gut wrenching accounts their real strength is the fact that the actors standing in for the men and women interviewed are all graduate students or recent graduates of the Temple University Drama Department makes it easy to imagine any one of them not just being stand-ins for the veterans whose stories comprise this drama, but BEING them. Perhaps its the young actors' own awareness of this "there for the grace of God go I" that has enabled them to perform so forcefully.

While as many of the soldiers you'll meet, joined the National Guard as their chief means of paying for college and accessing a better life, there are just as many for whom a career in the military was the culmination of a long held dream, and a chance to get away from their small towns. Patriotism and belief in the war's mission is much in evidence. But so is bitter disillusion. Certainly the episode with Kelly Dougherty, the young woman heading the the Iraq anti-war grouphardly tosses a bouquet of roses at President Bush, ending as it does with her talking about the people who don't really want to hear about what went on over there and how she can't reconcile her mother's "I support you and I'm proud of you" with her "voting for a president who is doing such horrible things" which might equally have led to her coming home in a flag-draped casket.

Of course just looking at and listening to young people facing lives without legs or hands and filled with nightmarish memories is in and of itself a powerful anti-war statement. But while you may find In Conflict hard to watch, as one of the men, Herold Noel, puts it "The hardest thing about being in Iraq is being in Iraq."

As of October 7th, In Conflict will run in rotating rep (every other week) with Ronan Noone's solo play The Atheist starring Campbell Scott and directed by Justin Waldman. You can see what it's about by reading our review of Scott's bravura performance as Augustine Early during the show's run at last summer's Williamstown Theatre Festival: The Atheist review.

In Conflict
Adapted and directed by Douglas C. Wager, based on the book of same name by Yvonne Latty
Cast: Tim Chambers, Stan Demidoff, Ethan Haymes, Amanda Holston, Suyeon Kim, Sean Lally, Joy Notoma, Sam Paul, Danielle Pinnock, Tom Rader, Damon Williams
Sets: Andrew Laine
Lighting: J. Dominic Chacon
Sound: Christopher Cappello and Paull Winnick
Costumes: Marian Cooper
Video: Warren Bass
Running Time: Approximately 2 hours and 15 minutes, including an intermission
Culture Project presentation of Temple University Production at Barrow Street Theatre 212-352-3101
From 9/18/08; opening 9/24/08; closing 11/16/08
Tue - Thu at 8pm; Fri & Sat at 9pm; Sat & Sun at 4pm (every other week)
Tickets: $35$25 during previews
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer September 20th
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of In Conflict
  • I disagree with the review of In Conflict
  • The review made me eager to see In Conflict
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email.

South Pacific  Revival
South Pacific

In the Heights
In the Heights

Playbill 2007-08 Yearbook

Leonard Maltin's Classic Movie Guide
Leonard Maltin's 2008 Movie Guide


©Copyright 2008, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from