The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings







Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review
Knives and Other Sharp Objects

Just say it, Lydia. Say what you want to say instead of dancing around it all the time. Tell me how much you hate my family. Come on! Tell me how much you resent their presence in my life. And how you tried to drive me away from them all these years. (To his nieces:) This is me, Lydia! No matter how much you want to change that. These young ladies are me. I am them. I look at them and I see everything that I left behind..—Jaime
Noemi Del Rio and Joselin Reyes
(Photo: Ari Mintz)
Raul Castillo has stuffed his Knives and Other Sharp Objects with enough characters for several dramas; in fact, too much so to do full justice to the powerful Mexican-American family saga at its heart. But then this is part of the invaluable LAB series which gives audiences a chance to see new plays in their developmental stage. These productions are minimally staged but thoroughly professional in terms of the participating actors and directors. At just $10 a ticket (and no, that isn't just for seniors and students!) these evenings at the small Shiva Theater can be richly satisfying theatrical experiences. Castillo's play, even though it still needs fine tuning, is no exception.

The patriarchs at the play's center are two brothers who have chosen different life paths. Jaime (Jaime Tirelli), the younger brother, has pursued the American dream. He moved to Austin, Texas and married Lydia (a marvelously cold and bitchy Candy Buckley), an unhyphenated American, and made lots of money working for an oil company. The older brother, who we never see, has chosen to remain in his Mexican border home town. His having turned his back on his brother's offer to help him to also become rich and assimilated has caused an estrangement so that there's been little contact between the men, their wives or their daughters. But now the older brother is dying and his wife has asked Jaime to take in her girls so that they would be spared the pain of watching their father's suffering. Jaime has agreed to take them in and pay for Beatrice (Noemi Del Rio) to attend the same Catholic school where his own younger daughter Lucy (Ana Nogueira) is enrolled. Alex (Joselin Reyes), Beatrice's older sister, who had been making a life for herself in Mexico but came home to be with the family, comes along mostly to protect Beatrice and keep her out of trouble.

The play begins with the two border town sisters on a a bus headed to their relatives' home (Sarah Sidman's lighting manages to evoke the sense of being on a bus even though it consists of just two chairs). Castillo's dialogue colorfully and naturally fills in lots of important plot details. That first scene, with a strong assist from Reyes' and Nogueira's excellent performances, establishes the sister dynamic and gives us a lot of family history.

The tensions that the sisters are leaving behind turns out to have its counterpart in Austin. It seems Uncle Jaime has been fired from his job and the family has had to downsize to a smaller house. Compared to what Alex and Beatrice are used to, they're still pretty well off but the change in status and income has take its toll on Lydia's and Jaime's marriage and had Lydia been consulted the nieces would not have been invited for this extended visit.

While the situation is a chance for the cousins to get to know each other and be friends, it also underscores the cultural differences within the family. For the already unhappy Jaime living with his nieces brings fresh awareness of what abandoning his roots has cost him. Alex's protectiveness of her sister points to the sturdiness of family ties that's lacking in the Americanized Austin family. An overlapping scene between Lydia and her daughter and Alex (as stand-in mother) and Lydia potently illustrates the different values.

As if there weren't enough complications in the lives of these uprooted sisters and the troubled household in which they are temporarily re-planted, there are two subplots, not to mention a homosexual element. The main one involves Manuel (Michael Ray Escamilla), another Mexican-American. He enters the picture during the girls' bus trip to Austin and is in even more of a crisis than they are (a family revenge act that went further than intended). I won't go into details about his backstory, but it brings on a sinister additional character named Eddie (David Anzuelo) and becomes closely but somewhat distractingly interwoven with the main plot.

The second subplot introduces Harvey (Ed Vasallo) and Perry (Angelo Rosso), two Army guardsmen who Loren (Amanda Perez) (accompanied by an unenthusiastic Alex) picks up at a Hooter's Bar & Grill . Hooter's is also used for a pickup scene in Christopher Durang's Why Torture Is Wrong, And Those Who Love Them (review) currently at the Public's Newman Theater. It's easy to understand why Durang and Castillo both thought this chain's self-proclaimed "delightfully tacky yet unrefined" atmosphere perfectly suited to their plays. Given the economic pressures felt by non-profit theaters, it would be nice if Hooter's repaid this coincidental double plug with a contribution to the Public Theater.

Though director Felix Solis keeps the additional plot strands from turning into too much of a tangle, they do tend to detract from the more powerful and primary family drama. This is especially true for the business with the Guardsmen. Manuel's story is more in keeping with the theme of shifting and colliding cultures and does give us the captivating Michael Ray Escamilla as Manuel. It's also Manuel who explains the meaning of the knife in the title ("I've been carrying around this knife with me for a long time. It belonged to my father. And his father before that. I inherited it after my old man passed away. When I was a boy, I used to stare at this knife like it was something magnificent. Like if it had all the power in the world and I couldn't wait till one day it was all mine. But I don't want it no more. I want you to take it from me").

Knives and Other Sharp Plays will be at the Shiva for just another week. It's well worth seeing even though it needs more work to realize its full potential.

Knives and Other Sharp Objects
By Raul Castillo
Directed by Felix Solis
Cast: David Anzuelo (Eddie), Candy Buckley (Lydia),, Noemi Del Rio (Beatrice), Michael Ray Escamilla (Manuel), Ana Nogueira (Lucy), Amanda Perez (Loren), Joselin Reyes (Alex), Angelo Rosso (Perry), Jaime Tirelli (Jaime)Ed Vassallo (Harvey).
Scenic design: Peter Ksander
Costume design: Ilona Somogyi
Lighting design: Sarah Sidman
Sound design: Bray Poor
Stage manager: Melissa Rae Miller
Public Theater, 420 Lafayette Street 212-967-755
Running time: approximately 2 hours and 10 minutes with one intermission
From 3/27/09; opening 4/12/09; closing 4/19/09
Tickets, $10
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer 4/10/08
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Knives and Other Sharp Objects
  • I disagree with the review of Knives and Other Sharp Objects
  • The review made me eager to see Knives and Other Sharp Objects
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

You can also contact us at Curtainup at Facebook or Curtainup at Twitter
Try for great seats to
Jersey Boys
The Little Mermaid
Lion King
Shrek The Musical

South Pacific  Revival
South Pacific

In the Heights
In the Heights

Playbill 2007-08 Yearbook

Leonard Maltin's Classic Movie Guide
Leonard Maltin's 2008 Movie Guide


©Copyright 2009, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from