The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings







Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review
Amazing Grace
There are moments when the waves of history converge. When the transformation of one man can change the world. With his hands John Newton enslaved thousands, but with his words he helped to free millions. — Pakuteh

Amazing Grace
Erin Mackey and Josh Young (Photo: Joan Marcus)
Far from light-hearted but deeply felt and spiritedly envisioned, Amazing Grace impressively joins the much heralded Hamilton (still previewing prior to its official opening on Broadway) as another stirring historical period musical adventure. This ambitious new musical is set during the mid 18th century with music and lyrics by Christopher Smith. The book by Smith and Arthur Giron is based on the tumultuous/conflicted life of English slave trader John Newton (Josh Young) who is primarily known for writing the beloved hymn that gives the musical its apt name.

Despairingly real events and dastardly doings are primarily afoot under the superb direction of Gabriel Barre. The compelling story follows the head-strong and brash Newton's defiance of his autocratic father Captain Newton (Splendid performance by Tom Hewitt, the owner of a slave trading company, through his progressive misfortunes and eventual redemption.

The musical asks the question: Will he at long last earn the respect of the beautiful Mary (Erin Mackey) the woman he has loved since his youth? Well, we know the answer. But this comes after years of profiting in the slave trade, well learned from the family-run business in Chatham, England. It is Newton's willful misadventures and his misguided values that make him an interesting if also atypical anti-hero.

There is curiously little to like or admire about this otherwise good-looking chap. e The Newton we first meet is a tenacious and arrogant young man. His testy relationship with the inflexible father sends him off to sea on one of the slave ships as punishment. While rooting for Newton isn't easy, but Young, whose performance as Judas in the most recent revival of Jesus Christ Superstar earned him a Tony nomination delivers a sturdy, emotion-fueled performance that is further buoyed by his robust singing.

If you were fortunate to see and hear Mackey as Johanna in Lincoln Center's Sweeney Todd and/or as Oona in Chaplin , you can now see her radiance on display here as a brave young woman who chooses activism as her ethical duty in the morally corrupt society in which she lives. Part of that radiance is now coming from the resplendent gowns designed for her by Toni-Leslie James.

The concise, reasonably romanticized book by Christopher Smith and Arthur Giron presumably takes some liberties with the facts surrounding Newton's change of heart as well as with some of the reasons for his political and religious awakening. It is also quite admirably neither compromises nor white-washes the deplorable decisions Newton makes and digressive courses he takes on his path to his spiritual awakening. Long abandoned are the songs and poems he wrote in his youth and which initially sparked Mary's love for him.

This show clearly follows the diverging paths taken by Newton and his despairing sweetheart. Their stories are structured to run parallel but they also steer a straight course toward a mutual destiny. Newton's harrowing experiences as a slave trader finds him caught in a blistering relationship with a seductive and also brutal African princess (a chilling Harriett D. Foy). This affords an opportunity for some vibrant tribal dancing by choreographer Christopher Gattelli which adds a pulsating texture to the scenes set in Sierra Leone and on the island of Barbados. In England, Mary agrees to be a spy for a group of abolitionists and becomes the girlfriend of the aristocrat Major Gray (a drolly supercilious performance by Chris Hoch) who condones the slave trade. Laiona Michelle as Mary's protector/nursemaid slave Nanna is a standout.

A huge unit setting of masts, ropes and pulleys by Eugene Lee and Edward Pierce provides multiple locations with ease. All are dramatically lighted by Ken Billington & Paul Miller. Credit also sound designer Jon Weston for the many crashes and booms along the way that help thrill the thrill-seekers in two spectacularly staged scenes: A sudden attack at sea by rival French slavers that sends Newton overboard and drowning, with an awesome undersea rescue i by Newton's devoted slave Thomas (a touching and memorable performance by the always excellent Chuck Cooper.) . . . In the second act a ferocious hurricane cripples the vessel but not the crew leading to Newton's epiphany. It is also the cue for the full ensemble to sing the title song and the musical's impassioned ending.

It is quite laudable that this first professional writing of Smith whom shall we say has covered all the bases (save for the title hymn and an appropriately integrated "Hail Britannia"). It remains to be seen whether his lilting arias and stirring anthems and the the impressive text will ultimately validate him as a major musical find? What I do know is that Smith and his production associates have given us an amazing show with an abundance of grit and grace.

Amazing Grace
Music and Lyrics by Christopher Smith
Book by Christopher Smith and Arthur Giron
Directed by Gabriel Barre

Cast of Principals: Chuck Cooper (Pakukeh, Thomas), Josh Young (John Newton), Tom Hewitt (Captain Newton) Stanley Bahorek (Robert Haweis), Erin Mackey (Mary Catlett), Laiona Michelle (Nanna), Elizabeth Ward Land (Mrs. Catlett), Chris Hoch (Major Gray), Harriett D. Foy (Princess Peyai), Rachel Ferrera (Yema) Scenic Design: Eugene Lee, Ward Price
Costume Design: Toni-Leslie James
Lighting Design: Ken Billingtron & Paul Miller
Sound Design: Jon Weston
Hair Design: Robert-Charles Vallance
Fight & Military Movement: David Leong
Orchestrations: Kenny Seymour
Musical Coordinator: Michael Keller
Music Direction, Arrangements & Incidental Music: Joseph Church Choreography: Christopher Gattelli
Associate Choreographer: Shanna Vanderwerker
Production Stage Manager: Paul J. Smith
Running time: 2 hours 30 minutes including intermission
Nederlander Theatre, 208 W 41st St.
Tickets: $65-$139
Performances: Week of July 13: Monday at 8 PM, Tuesday at 8 PM, Wednesday at 2 PM & 8 PM, Saturday at 2 PM & 8 PM, Sunday at 3 PM. Beginning week of July 20: Tuesday at 7 PM, Wednesday at 2 PM & 8 PM, Thursday at 7 PM, Friday at 8 PM, Saturday at 2 PM & 8 PM, Sunday at 3 PM. From 06/25/15 Opened 07/16
Review by Simon Saltzman based on performance 07/14/15
Musical Numbers
Act One
    Prologue -- Pakuteh/Thomas (Chuck Cooper) Truly Alive -- John Newton (Josh Young), Captain Newton (Tom Hewitt) The Auction -- John Newton Someone Who Hears -- Mary Catlett (Erin Mackey) and John Newton Yema's Song -- Yema (Rachael Ferrera, Nanna (Laiona Michelle) and Ensemble Voices of the Angels -- Mary Catlett Rule Britannia -- Mary Catlett and Company We Are Determined -- Mr. Tyler (Mike Evariste), Mr. Einhorn (Michael Dean Morgan), Mr. Quigley (Vince Oddo) and Company Each and Every Life -- Thomas (Chuck Cooper) No Negotiation -- Briggs (Gavriel Savit) and Sailors Never -- John Newton Shadows of Innocence -- John Newton, Mary Catlett and Ensemble Expectations -- Major Gray (Chris Hoch)
Act Two
    Welcome Song -- Princess Peyai (Harriett D. Fpy) and Ensemble Sing on High -- The Company Tell Me Why -- Mary Catlett Yema's Song (Reprise) -- Yema A Chance for Me -- Captain Newton Nowhere Left to Run -- Thomas Daybreak -- Nanna I Still Believe -- Mary Catlett Testimony -- John Newton I Will Remember -- John Newton Rule Britannia (Reprise) -- Mary Catlett Nothing There to Love -- John Newton and Mary Catlett Amazing Grace -- Company
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Amazing Grace
  • The review made me eager to see Amazing Grace
  • I disagree with the review of Amazing Grace
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted add to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter
Subscribe to our FREE email updates: E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message. If you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
The New Similes Dictionary

©Copyright 2015, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from