The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings







Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review
The Heiress

"My father won’t abuse you. He doesn’t know you well enough."
— Catherine Sloper assuring impoverished suitor Morris Townsend that he need not worry about Doctor Sloper's treating him unkindly. She should know as she's long suffered from her father's psychological abuse, though it isn't until the final act that she finally stands up to him and rejects his attempted compassion with "Don’t be kind to me, Father! It doesn’t become you."
The Heiress
David Strathairn and Jessica Chastain
(Photo credit: Joan Marcus)
Henry James remains one of our much read and written about master novelists. But he was a failed playwright.

It took later writers to realize the dramatic potential of his stories for stage and screen. Case in point: The Heiress, the 1997 hit play Ruth and Augustus Goetz adapted from the James 1880 novella Washington Square. The pair's smart craftsmanship incorporated James' incisive dialogue into the combination romance and psychological thriller. They also renamed it, to shift the focus from the story's location to its financially well off but personality challenged main character. The Heiress thus represents page to stage adaptation and the well-made drama that dominated that era at their very best.

The title role won an Oscar for Olivia DeHaviland in the 1949 movie version and the first of two Tony awards for Cherry Jones in the play's last Broadway revival in 1995 (Katie Finneran who's currently Miss Hannigan in the Broadway revival of Annie, played the maid in that production. Virginia Krull serves Dr. Slper's sherry with equal charm) .Now the story of the painfully shy, awkward, naive young woman smitten with a charming but poor young man is back on Broadway. It's likely to make Jessica Chastain, an actress best known for her film and, TV work more of a live theater regular.

To use Catherine Sloper's favorite adjective, this new production offers a pretty wonderful old-fashioned good time. Henry James's words still retain their power. While this doesn't seem like a play to appeal to Moises Kaufman, he expertly directs the blue ribbon cast to capture every psychological nuance and the considerable humor without resorting to trendy 21st century references. The stagecraft is gorgeous. In short, while we've had a plethora of revivals, this one makes a strong case for not relegating the well-made genre — at least not the one with solid literary roots — to the theatrical dustbin. At close to three hours, this revival flies by more entertainingly than a lot of today's stylishly trim ninety-minute plays.

Whether you've seen a previous stage production or caught the movie on TCM, you won't want to miss visiting Derek McLane's richly detailed replica of Dr. Austin Sloper's elegant mid-19th century town house on Washington Square circa 1850. While McLane is one of New York's busiest and most versatile set designers, I could have sworn that the Sloper townhouse was the work of John Lee Beatty who has a reputation for creating this sort of rich milieu. (Beatty actually did design the 1995 production). The plush setting is further enhanced by Albert Wolsky's authentic and lush costumes for the genteel residents and visitors.

As anyone who saw her in The Help can confirm, Jessic a Chastain, like other actresses playing the plain Jane title character, is hardly an ugly duckling, But then Catherine Sloper's awkwardness, and plainness is more a case of being psychologically diminished by her too judgmental, unloving father than being ugly. With her own hair hidden beneath an unflattering wig by wig wizard Paul Huntley, hat allows Chastain, to evoke spinsterish mediocrity with her facial expression, body language. She impressively conveys the tragedy of a woman who, raised in a less self-esteem killing environment, could well be capable of being wonderful, rather than too timid to nurture her innate wit

David Straithairn walks in the footsteps of Basil Rathbone, Ralph Richardson and Philip Bosco as the doctor who, in his inability to let go of grief over his beautiful wife, gives the daughter who survived all the advantages of his wealth but without the warmth and genuine affection she yearns for. His hope that she will somehow grow up to make up for his years as a lonely widower is an impossible dream that understandably has a crippling effect on his daughter. Straithairn admirably achieves the difficult task of making the stern Doctor understandable yet unsympathetic to the very end. His confrontations with Morris Townsend, the suitor he sees as a fortune hunter totally lacking in his own work ethic.

For many in the audience who became Dan Stevens fans courtesy of Downton Abbey , his playing the handsome, luxury loving fortune hunter Morris Townsend is the big draw. At the performance I attended, his arrival brought a rush of sighs and applause from female audience members.

Stevens is appropriately charming and amusing, perhaps a tad too much so, but his instant and aggressive pursuit leaves little doubt that Dr. Sloper is right in his assessment of his character and intentions. His portrayal deepens and becomes more interesting as he must manipulate Catherine to remain convinced of his sincerity yet keep her from breaking with the father and forfeiting her inheritance. Even as Dr. Sloper reveals Morris's careless disregard of his widowed sister's needs, he manages to avoid being an out and out villain. Sure, he would probably spend Catherine's fortune too freely, but living with him would certainly be more joyous for the love-starved young woman than life with her father has been.

What really accounts for the play's durability is its powerful portrait of an emotionally damaged woman who frees herself from the need to win the approval of the father who could never look at her without blaming her for her mother's death, and whose resentment is deepened by her being so disappointingly unlike her lovely and graceful mother. Ultimately, what fascinates is not so much the love story but watching Catherine empower herself to be the master of her own fate. While there's never any doubt about the outcome of her relationship with both the father she allowed to diminish her and the lover she allowed to deceive her, the fascination and suspense derives from how and when it's all going to unfold.

Predictable as it all is, the Jamesian wit and characterizations still engage us emotionally. The play is at its most painfully compelling during the scene when Dr. Sloper, in his role as his daughter's protector , finally abandons any pretense of covering up his disdain and disrespect. When Catherine. persists in her conviction that it's not her money that made Morris want her, he brutally counters with "What else then, Catherine? Your beauty? Your grace? Your charm? Your quick tongue and subtle wit?" In disgust he adds, "You embroider neatly." No wonder that she can explain the cruel streak that is part of her final act with "I've been taught by masters!"

Dr. Sloper's sisters, Lavinia Penniman (Judith Ivey) and Elizabeth Allmond (Caitlin O'Conell) are helpless witnesses to this incredibly brutal encounter between father and daughter. The expression on their faces reflects our own horror.

The sisters are among the ensemble standouts . Judith Ivey is especially delightful as the flirty widow who has been asked by her brother to extend her visit, hopefully to help her niece overcome her shyness. While her bubbly personality doesn't rub off on Catherine, she is as smitten with Morris as her niece and thus an active aide-de-camp in fostering his suit. The other sister is less romantic. However, as her realism has made her accept a less than ideal young man, Arthur Townsend (Kieran Campion), as her pretty but flighty daughter Marian's (Molly Camp) fiance, so she feels overlooking Morris Townsend's mercenary motifs might nevertheless be a fair trade-off for Catherine's happiness.

The transparency of Morris's intentions and the ending is too facile for The Heiress to be a great play. But it' nevertheless a still absorbing theatrical experience.

The Heiress
Ruth & Augustus Goetz adaptation of James Novel
Directed by Moisés Kaufman
Cast: Jessica Chastain (Catherine), Judith Ivey (Lavinia Penniman), David Strathairn (Dr. Austin Sloper), Dan Stevens (Morris Townsend) KieranCampion (Elizabeth Almond), Kieran Campion (Arthur Townsend), Virginia Kull (Maria), Marian Almond (Molly Camp), Dee Nelson (Mrs. Montgomery), Ben Livingston (Coachman).
Sets: Derek McLane
Costumes: Albert Wolsky
Lighting: David Lander
Original Music: Peter Golub
Sound: Leon Rothenberg
Original Music: Peter Gollub
Hair and Wig Design: Paul Huntley
Stage Manager: Arthur Gaffin
Running Time: 2 hours and 45 minutes with intermission
Walter Kerr Theatre 219 W. 48th St. 212/239-6200
From 10/06/12; opening 11/01/12; closing 2/10/13.
Tickets $50.00-$135.00.
Tuesday at 7:00PM, Wednesday at 2:00PM & 8:00PM, Thursday at 7:00PM, Friday at 8:00PM, Saturday at 2:00PM & 8:00PM and Sunday at 3:00PM
Reviewed by Elyse Sommer at October 27th press preview.
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of  The Heiress
  • I disagree with the review of The Heiress
  • The review made me eager to see The Heiress
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

Visit Curtainup's Blog Annex
For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted add to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter
Subscribe to our FREE email updates: E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message. If you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
Slings & Arrows  cover of  new Blu-Ray cover
Slings & Arrows- view 1st episode free

Anything Goes Cast Recording Anything Goes Cast Recording
Our review of the show

Book Of Mormon MP4 Book of Mormon -CD
Our review of the show

©Copyright 2012, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from