The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings

Search Curtainup








NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review
It's Only a Play

February 25, 2015 update: Nathan Lane who left to take on the role of Hickey in The Iceman Cometh at Bam will return as of March 31 for the rest of the run. January 4, 2015 update: Nathan Lane, Rupert Grint and Megan Mullally leave the play, with Martin Short, Maulik Pancholy and Katie Finneran taking over their roles on 1/07/15. The entire production will move to the Bernard B. Jacobs Theatre at 242 West 45th Street 1/23/15, until its again extended closing date, 6/07/15.
Guess who just walked in down there and handed me his coat? Al Pacino! Can you believe it? This place is crawling with famous people. Donald Trump looked right at me and asked me for a glass of Dom Perignon. I told him I was taking coats. My first night in New York and I'm High-Fiving Denzel Washington. I'm pretty sure I saw Rosie O'Donnell talking to the Pope.
— Gus, reporting to the man who got him the job as greeter and coat taker at an opening night party in the producer's home. He hopes this contact with all the celebrities will open the door for him to use his skills as an "actor-slash-singer-slash-dancer-slash-comedian-slash-performance artist-slash-mime."
It's Only a Play
Megan Mullally and Nathan Lane (Photo: Joan Marcus)
Question: How do you turn an Off-Broadway flop into a Broadway hit?

Answer: Re-unite Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick to play an actor who abandoned the stage for a money making TV series and a playwright whose play presciently named The Golden Egg is opening on Broadway.

Since Lane and Broderick are indeed playing actor James Wicker and playwright Peter Austin, it doesn't really matter what I or any other critic says about Terence McNally's update of the 1986 backstage comedy It's Only A Play which was already an update of a 1982 one. That would apply even if this review were as scathing as McNally's version for New York Times critic Ben Brantley which happens to be one of the play's funniest segments. The chance to see Lane and Broderick together on a Broadway stage again has sent ticket sales soaring even before the opening. The press performance I attended was standing room only.

And so, to paraphrase one of New Yorks most colorful former Mayors Ed Koch, how are they doing? Has McNally's update finally given his cri de coeur for keeping the theater alive while also poking fun at those who are (or would like to be) part of that world its just due?

Micah Stock
Michah stock (Photo: Joan Marcus)
Lane is better than ever. He lands every zinger (of which there's no shortage) with impeccable timing and his facial expressions are priceless. However, Lane's best and funniest interchanges are not with Matthew Broderick but with Micah Stock's Gus. Stock is hilarious as the young New York newbie and aspiring actor temping as greeter and coat checker at the farcical play-within-a-play post-opening party at producer Julia Budder's town house (stylishly designed by Scott Pask). Actually I wasn't surprised at Stock's terrific debut, having seen him last year in a brand-new McNally play, And Away We Go presented off-Broadway, with Stock joining the Pearl Theater Company's resident actors.

As for McNally's play. This is my first viewing of It's Only A Play. I therefore can't compare this latest rendition to its 17-performance Off-Broadway run in 1986, which was already an update of a 1982 Off-Off-Broadway production seen by even fewer people. It's nevertheless easy to see why the butts of McNally's jokes and the details about how opening nights played out then had to be brought up-to-date. It's also easy to see why the need for theater goers to be conversant with all the abundantly dropped names of people and plays probably contributed to the flop-length run despite considerable praise from thos3 who saw it. Maybe the superstar casting (one of McNally's satirical targets) and the social media's proliferation making for heightened celebrity know-how will continue to fill every seat in the Schoenfeld Theatre through, and perhaps beyond, its January closing date.

Though the caveat that a good many of the jokes will go over the heads of the celebrity challenged still applies, McNally is an expert farceur. The new It's Only a Play also benefits from several other fun to watch performances.

Stockard Channing is a hoot as Virginia Noyes, The Golden Egg's leading lady. The pharmaceutical loving Noyes prompts the ever ready with a back stab Wicker to comment "They drummed her out of Hollywood and she came crawling back to Broadway." He expands on this with "The theater has become the Statue of Liberty for movie actors" paraphrasing its motto as "Give us your tired, your poor, your washed up, your strung out."

Also very funny is F. Murray Abraham as Ira Drew, an acerbic critic who never forgets what he wrote about an actor though he does forget to get their names right. He's also a closet playwright.

On the other hand, Rupert Grint doesn't quite live up to any expectations fans of his Harry Potter films probably have. The funniest and most memorable aspect of his role as Frank Fingers, the aptly named kleptomaniac and avant-garde British director, is as another target for Lane's wickedly sardonic Wicker ("you're talking to someon who actually sat through his all-male Medea at BAM. I took my poor mother. I think it's what killed her"). Ann Roth, one of this production's unseen stars, makes Fingera visual gut buster with a weird grisaille patterned suit. Roth also deserves a special hand for the non-verbal comic contributions provided by the guests' outer wear that Stock's Gus keeps bringing up from the main floor.

Megan Mullaly's Julia Budder made me wish I could have seen Christine Baranski when she played this part in 1986. Mullally would have been well served if the otherwise excellent director Jack O'Brien had persuaded her to deliver her lines in a lower pitch. This is the second time in a week that I've seen an actress succumb to shrillness.

Last, and unfortunately least enjoyable, to arrive in the play-within's bedroom is Matthew Broderick as the author of the play everyone has high hopes for — which doesn't necessarily mean for its success. The sing-song voice and stance of someone with a stiff neck that worked like a charm for Broderick's "I Want to Be a Producer" here simply seems stiff. He starts out well enough with a droll, self-deprecating admission that hearing people yelling "Author! Author!" when he walked into the party it wasn't his dream come true but for Tom Stoppard he was right behind him. After that, his very presence seems to have the effect of a balloon losing its air. In fairness to Broderick, McNally is largely to blame for this since he saddles this character with much too lengthy diatribes about his more serious (and, alas, preachy) concerns.

The play gets back on its comic track for the second act's opening, with the cast members taking turns reading Ben Brantley-à-la-McNally evisceration of everyone connected with The Golden Egg. While the various characters come and go, fortunately Nathan Lane's Wicker is almost always on. And it's as an insider joke fest and a farce, that It's Only a Play is best. As a sorrowful memorial to a by-gone theatrical world, mostly by Broderick as McNally's stand-in, it's a kvetch that seems blind to the fact that this production has itself embraced all these complaints, while some fine American plays are indeed being done on Broadway and high profile off-Broadway stages — including Mr. Lane's own exemplary The Nance which is happily reaching non-traditional audiences via television.

The gossipy name dropping is fun and the funny business has much of the audience in stitches. Still, I left the theater wishing that it really were more of a play.

It's Only a Play by Terrence McNally
Directed by Jack O'Brien
Cast: F. Murray Abraham (Ira Drew), Matthew Broderick (Peter Austin), Stockard Channing (Virginia Noyes), Nathan Lane (James Wicker), Megan Mullally (Julia Budder), Rupert Grint (Frank Finger), Micah Stock (Gus P. Head)
Sets: Scott Pask
Costumes: Ann Roth
Lighting: Philip S. Rosenberg
Sound: Fitz Patton
Hair, Wig and Make-up: Campbell Young Associates
Stage Manager: Jane Grey
Running Time: 2 and 35 minutes, which includes an intermission
Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre 236 West 45th Street (212) 239-620
From 8/28/14; opening 10/09/14; closing 6/07/15 with Martin Short taking over for Nathan Lane 1/07/15.
The original closing, extended and now closing 3/29/1t-- but with Martin Short stepping in for Nathan Lane as of 1/07/15.
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of It's Only a Play
  • I disagree with the review of It's Only a Play
  • The review made me eager to see It's Only a Play
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted add to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter
Subscribe to our FREE email updates: E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message. If you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
The New Similes Dictionary
New Similes Dictionary

Slings & Arrows  cover of  new Blu-Ray cover
Slings & Arrows- view 1st episode free

Book Of Mormon MP4 Book of Mormon -CD
Our review of the show

©Copyright 2014, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from