The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings








Etcetera and
Short Term Listings


NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
Writing for Us
A CurtainUp London London Review
Lost Boy

"Stop standing like that! Grown Ups don't unless they are in an operetta." — Wendy on seeing the Peter Pan stance, legs akimbo and hands on hips
Lost Boy
Steven Butler as Peter Pan and Grace Gardner as Wendy (Photo: Scott Rylander)
Phil Willmott's new musical was inspired by thinking about the young men going to war in France in the First World War where those, who as children had read JM Barrie's book about Neverland and the boy who wouldn't grow up. And what a forcing of maturity was that great war for so many who we shall remember this year being 100 years since the opening of hostilities. A million died from our shores alone and twice as many more were wounded, left physically and emotionally scarred by the battle.

Lost Boy the musical opens with one of Barrie's adopted children, George Llewelyn Davies (Steven Butler), one of the five orphaned brothers who is a captain in the British Army and who we are told carried a small copy of Peter Pan with him. Captain Llewelyn Davies' story frames this musical, a dreamscape which explores what would have happened to Peter Pan, Wendy, the Lost Boys, Tinker Bell and Tiger Lilly if they had grown up in real time.

Wendy (Grace Gardner) is reunited with Peter Pan (Steven Butler). Peter is still a quirky, petulant child and she is a little mother, calm and assuring and obviously thrilled to see Peter again for the song "The Blue Lagoon", in this finely cast production. The circle widens and Peter meets up with the Lost Boys, now married and working in "offices." This sees the Lost Boys celebrating the end of the week in white ties and tails for the Friday night bash in "Lost Boys Reunion" in Kensington Gardens and brings Peter up to speed.

"Loving a Lost Boy" introduces Wendy to the Lost Wives Club, the women who have married the Lost Boys. What Wendy might be taking on with one of these men, who are still really childlike is explained as the women expand on their husbands' idiosyncrasies.

Peter and Wendy plan a wedding in "Marry Me" and Mr Darling (Andrew C Wadsworth) talks about parenting Wendy without his wife in "Loving a Lost Child." We meet Wendy's brothers: bespectacled John (Richard James-King) who we last saw flying in a top hat and pyjamas and Michael, the youngest Darling boy (Joseph Taylor) then in his blue onesy. John is rather geeky and studious in a tweed suit but Michael's story is altogether wilder and imaginative. Michael has rebelled and ends up at the Music Hall with a flying trapeze artist lover, Geronimo. "Michael's Song" is a highlight as he tells us "And I flew" recreating the excitement flying with Peter Pan and is beautifully choreographed by Racky Plews. Michael is lifted high up and his exuberant personality raises everybody's spirits.

The music hall scene extends to Captain Illusion (Andrew C Wadsworth) whose magic tricks are executed with one arm behind his back. "Smoke and Mirrors/Sleight of Hand" has the showgirls using silver fans to dance around the magician whom Wendy recognises from her past. Peter and Wendy's wedding is disrupted and without telling you how, a naughty fairy reappears (Joanna Woodward) whose sad fate without her wings is to make a living in the oldest profession. Her life is explored in "Slip Into Darkness".

Act Two opens with another witty standout song as the geeky John explains "Jungian Dream Analysis". I don't remember a song about psychoanalysis and getting collective unconsciousness into the lyric is clever, tying this up with our shadows (remember Peter had lost his and Wendy sewed it back on) while the cast behind grimace and writhe and threaten. This musical captures the personalities of the Darling children and perfectly transposes them to adult life with ideal casting completing the transition. "Dragons" sees Captain Hook in an opium den as he confronts his own shadows. To Paris with the Lost Boys who have joined the army for a burlesque number "Ooh La La" where we again meet Tiger Lilly (Natalie Lipin); lovely choreography in the Finborough's tiny space.

John leads the anti war protest with "Unite!" with a ballet sequence from Luka Marcus and Lauren Cocoracchio. The Lost Wives join a nursing corps tending to the wounded in France. The dream merges into nightmare and we return to Captain Llewelyn Davies' story in the trenches with a terrified soldier.

I liked the strong narrative arc for this sequel to Peter Pan with changes of scene and tempo providing vibrancy but remaining true to the original characterisation. The tuneful and varied songs incorporate ballads, music hall type numbers and spirited marches.

The performers work very hard. Their performances are in character, the singing is good and the three piece band dedicated. I especially admired Racky Plews' witty choreography. Joseph Taylor stands out as Michael with a huge personality, Steven Butler's Peter looks puzzled and is always expressive and Grace Gardner's Wendy has an elegant, grown up quality among the boys. The First World War context of Lost Boy strikes the evocative note of loss, the sad end to the "awfully big adventure".

Subscribe to our FREE email updates with a note from editor Elyse Sommer about additions to the website -- with main page hot links to the latest features posted at our numerous locations. To subscribe, E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message -- if you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
Lost Boy
Written, Composed and Directed by Phil Willmott
Co-composer, Arrangement and Orchestration by Mark Collins

Starring: Steven Butler, Grace Gardner, Joseph Taylor, Richard James-King, Andrew C Wadsworth, Joanna Woodward, Hannah Grace
With: Lauren Cocoracchio, Natalie Lipin, Luka Marcus, Max Panks, David Scotland
Set Design: Philip Lindley
Choreography by Racky Plews
Costume Design: Sophia Simensky
Sound: Jamie Nicholson
Lighting: Miguel Vicente
Musical Direction: Isaac McCullough
Running time: Two hours 20 minutes including one interval
Box Office: 0844 847 1652 Book online at
Booking at The Finborough booking to 11th January 2014
Booking at the Charing Cross Theatre from 13th January 2014 to 15th February 2014
Charing Cross Theatre Box Office 08444 930650 (booking fee applies) or book online at
Reviewed by Lizzie Loveridge based on 2nd January 2014 performance at The Finborough, 118 Finborough Road SW10 9ED (Tube: Earls Court)

Musical Numbers
Act One
  • Lost - George, Ensemble
  • The Blue Lagoon - Wendy, Peter
  • Lost Boys Reunion - Lost Boys, Peter
  • Loving a Lost Boy - Lost Wives
  • Marry Me - Peter, Wendy
  • Loving a Lost child - Mr Darling
  • Michael's Song and the Music Hall - Michael, Ensemble
  • Smoke and Mirrors/Sleight of Hand (Wensy's Dream) - Captain Hook
  • We are the Lost Boys - Lost Boys
  • Slip into the Darkness - Tinker Bell, Ensemble
  • The Wedding - Edith, Tootles, Wendy, Ensemble
  • Once More - Peter, Tootles, Wensy, Ensemble
Act Two
  • Jungian Dream Analysis - John, Ensemble
  • Dragons - Captain Hook
  • The Streets of Paris - Lost Boys
  • Ooh La La - Mistress Lilly, Lost Girls, Lost Boys
  • Unite! - John
  • Wendy's Song - Wendy
  • Unite! (Reprise) - Female Ensemble
  • Michael's Song (Reprise)/First Aid - Michael, Lost Wives
  • Bell's Story - Tinker Bell
  • Dragons (Reprise) - Peter
  • What About Me and You? - Captain Hook, Wendy, Ensemble
  • Act Two Finale (Lagoon Reprise) - Wendy Tinker Bell, Ensemble
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of Lost Boy
  • I disagree with the review of Lost Boy
  • The review made me eager to see Lost Boy
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email . . . also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

London Theatre Walks

Peter Ackroyd's  History of London: The Biography

London Sketchbook

tales from shakespeare
Retold by Tina Packer of Shakespeare & Co.
Click image to buy.
Our Review

©Copyright 2014, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from