The Internet Theater Magazine of Reviews, Features, Annotated Listings

Search Curtainup








NYC Restaurants


New Jersey







Free Updates
A CurtainUp Review
What I Did Last Summer

" This is a play about me when I was fourteen, back during the war, when we had this house at a place called Rose Hill, on the Canadian shore of Lake Erie, near Buffalo, New York, where I was born. . .That was the summer I planned to sit around the house. . ."
— Charlie
What I Did Last Summer
Noah Galvin and Kristine Nielsen (Photo: Joan Marcus)
Like the The Wayside Motor Inn , the first of A. R. Gurney's Signature Theater Residency plays, What I Did Last Summer isn't at the top tier of the prolific playwright's substantial oeuvre. Both plays had bumpy starts but have been given vivid new lives thanks to a pitch perfect cast and the insightful direction. What I Did Last Summer is an especially fruitful new collaboration between Mr. Gurney and Jim Simpson at the downtown Flea theater which Simpson founded and home to a number of Gurney's latest plays.

The present production rings true to its period and is astutely constructed in keeping with both Gurney and Simpson's dislike of spelling everything out with a lot of scenery. But while this is a production without a lot of eye-popping modern stage business, Michael Yeargan's set evokes a sense of a sandy lake front town. The design also makes splendid use of the growing effectiveness projections. Under Mr. Simpson's direction the essentially realistic family drama is fluidly integrated with the presentational style typical of Thornton Wilder's plays. My favorite new thing is the constant presence of percussionist Dan Wiener. What at first looks like a distracting gimmick serves both as an echo of the actors voices and adds the flavor of the once popular radio plays and the way they challenged audiences' imaginations.

When the summer during which the story unfolds ends, 14 almost 15-year-old Charlie has been on a voyage of self-discovery; but he still hasn't unearthed his creative potential. However, since Charlie is obviously a stand-in for the playwright who grew up in Buffalo, it's clear that this potential lies, not in the visual arts that an eccentric artist has him experiment with, but in playwriting. Given the details of that Lake Erie summer which becomes his first play, Charlie, like his creator, manages to break away from the constraints of his WASP background — but instead of abandoning it use it as rich and gently satirical fodder for his writing.

While What I Did Last Summer is presented as Charlie's own first play, Mr. Gurney was fifty-one or two when he wrote it and himself a parent of college age children. He'd been writing for many years but the big hits like The Dining Room, The Cocktail Hour, Love Letters and Sylvia were still on the horizon. So you might call this a coming to the brink of major success play for Mr. Gurney.

Charley as the "I" of the title claims this as being his story with his brief opening monologue. However, several similar audience addressing claims to that "I" broaden the coming of age classification into family drama.
First to lay claim to the story is Charlie's mother Grace (Carolyn McCormick, capturing the stresses of World War II making her a single mother as well as her susceptibility to sexual yearning). With her husband still overseas Grace hopes to retain a sense of normalcy by moving her family from its Buffalo house to their summer home in an upscale WASP community on Lake Erie.

But things aren't really more normal. Being still young, attractive and alone, makes it hard for Grace to keep her friendship with a male neighbor just that. And neither her son or daughter is a happy camper.

Charley (played with charm and intensity by Noah Galvin) would rather get a job than studying for another try at passing his Latin and helping Grace around the house. His 19-year-old sister Elsie (Kate McGonigle, a Julliard student making her off-Broadway debut) is grumpy and frustrated because she misses her dad and all the boys her age who are overseas. The tensions, especially between Charlie and Grace, extend to their different tastes in movies. (Charlie, unlike his mom, doesn't think Mrs. Miniver is worth seeing a second time).

To expand the family circle and underscore the tightness of this type of all-of-a-kind community, we meet three other characters: There's Bonny (Juliet Brett), the girl next door and Ted (Pico Alexande) the son of town's chief grounds keeper. It's okay for Charlie and Ted to pal around together, but Bonny's dad definitely would not be okay with this "townie" dating his daughter. While Bonny and Ted do affect how Charlie's summer ends, the really critical influence on Charlie is Anna Trumbull (Kristine Nielsen), an eccentric half Native American who became a rich man's mistress after her own family lost its fortune. She's now known as the Pig Woman, because the cottage left to her by that lover was once a pigsty.

One of the problems with the original New York production of this play was that most of the actors weren't good fits for their roles. That was especially true for the Anna Trumbull role. Not so, this time around. I can't think of anyone for whom eccentricity comes more naturally than Kristine Nielsen. She's a bit too over the top but it fits the part, and her interaction with Galvin's Noah works.

There's no getting away from the contrivance of the way the plot twists to reveal that Grace was once Anna's prize student and how that affected both hers and Anna's life. But even the women's twisty second act confrontation is affecting in the hands of the current actors and makes it easier to buy into Mr. Gurney's stated vision for building his plot around "the old captivity story, once popular in Puritan New England, where a child is stolen by Indians and becomes won over by the natural simplicity and freedom that comes with the Native American culture." Thus Gurney updated this situation by having Charley "captured" by the artsy, counter-culture Anna and leaving up to Grace to bring her son back into her "stockade." (see Gurney's web site:

The pleasures of this handsomely staged and well acted productions are abetted by the pitch-perfect period costumes and hairdos by Claudia Brown and Dave Bova; also Brian Aldous's mood supporting lighting when the John Narun's projections shift from the amusing typed text (taken verbatim from the script) to more evocative images.

Charlie's coming of age summer ends rather predictably and with the various plot threads dangling pretty loosely. And though this production won't turn this minor Gurney into a Gurney gem, does come closer to unearthing the play's potential to entertain the audience for all of its two hours.

Mr. Gurney's three-play residency will follow these two reinvigorated oldies with a world premiere called Love and Money. As always at the Signature, a ticket for a performance during the play's scheduled run represents New York's best theatrical bargain.

What I Did Last Summer by A.R. Gurney
Directed by Jim Simpson
Cast: Pico Alexander (Ted), Juliet Brett (Bonny), Noah Galvin (Charlie), Carolyn McCormick (Grace), Kate McGonigle (Elsie), Kristine Nielsen (Anna Trumbull). Sets: Michael Yeargan
Costumes: Claudia Brown
Lighting: Brian Aldous
Sound: Janie Bullard
Projections: John Narun
Wigs and Hair: Dave Bova
Stage Manager: Donald Fried
Running Time: Approx 2 hours including intermission
Irene Diamond Stage at The Pershing Square Signature Center 480 West 42nd Street
From 4/28/15; opening 5/17/15; closing 6/07/15
Tuesday - Friday at 7:30PM Saturday & Sunday at 2PM Wednesday matinees May 20, May 27 & June 3 at 2PM Sunday evening: May 3 7:30PM
Reviewed by Elyse sommer at May 13th press preview
Highlight one of the responses below and click "copy" or"CTRL+C"
  • I agree with the review of What I Did Last Summer
  • I disagree with the review of What I Did Last Summer
  • The review made me eager to see What I Did Last Summer
Click on the address link E-mail:
Paste the highlighted text into the subject line (CTRL+ V):

Feel free to add detailed comments in the body of the email. . .also the names and emails of any friends to whom you'd like us to forward a copy of this review.

For a feed to reviews and features as they are posted add to your reader
Curtainup at Facebook . . . Curtainup at Twitter
Subscribe to our FREE email updates: E-mail:
put SUBSCRIBE CURTAINUP EMAIL UPDATE in the subject line and your full name and email address in the body of the message. If you can spare a minute, tell us how you came to CurtainUp and from what part of the country.
The New Similes Dictionary
New Similes Dictionary

Slings & Arrows  cover of  new Blu-Ray cover
Slings & Arrows- view 1st episode free

Book Of Mormon MP4 Book of Mormon -CD
Our review of the show

©Copyright 2015, Elyse Sommer.
Information from this site may not be reproduced in print or online without specific permission from